Taxes and benefits

Research articles · Aug 31, 2011

A care time benefit as a timely alternative for the non-working spouse compensation in the Belgian tax system

Joris Ghysels, Josefine Vanhille, Gerlinde Verbist

Herman Deleeck Centre for Social Policy, University of Antwerp, Belgium

Volume 4(2) Autumn 2011

Cite as: J. Ghysels, J. Vanhille, G. Verbist; 2011; A care time benefit as a timely alternative for the non-working spouse compensation in the Belgian tax system; International Journal of Microsimulation; 4(2); 57–72. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00053

Abstract

Over the past decades, the growing labour force participation of mothers has rendered the Belgian personal income tax system increasingly outdated. Especially the ‘marital quotient’ system – that allows spouses with monetary income to transfer part of their tax base to a spouse without monetary income – is no longer a tax allowance that compensates childcare efforts. It rather has become a subsidy to older cohorts for their past childcare efforts. As an alternative, we model in this article a system that is geared towards the effective care trajectories of nowadays parents. We thereby follow earlier ideas of Hilde Bojer, Patricia Apps and Ray Rees to reflect care efforts in the tax base of individuals. Following Bojer, we propose a system that incorporates a socially grounded amount of childcare time in household income, and simulate this with the Belgian microsimulation model MISIM. The amount relates to the number and age of children and can either be procured through childcare services or self-provision. In the proposed system both market- and self-provided care result in a similar subsidy. We elaborate a monetary estimate of self-provided childcare on the basis of the detailed information of time use in the Flemish Family and Care Survey (2004-2005). For discussion we provide an overview of potential drawbacks and advantages and evaluate the redistributive impact of the simulated alternative.

This article contains 1 figure and 14 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Distribution of household types and average number of children over the income distribution.

Tables

Table 1. The distribution of paid employment among fathers in dual-earner families, hours per week.
N(observations) 574
Mean 43h11’
Percentiles
10 25.0 hours
25 38.0 hours
50 42.5 hours
75 51.0 hours
90 60.0 hours
95 68.0 hours

Source: FFCS (2004–2005).

Note: the original measurement is in half hour units.

Table 2. Time spent at schoo1 according to the age of the child, hours per week.
Age Median Mean S.E. Minimum Maximum N Proposal
0 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 45 0
1 0.00 0.23 0.17 0.00 9.75 69 0
2 0.00 6.52 1.48 0.00 43.42 60 0
3 24.96 22.49 1.63 0.00 40.00 46 25
4 28.43 27.25 1.30 0.00 49.75 46 28
5 31.50 29.66 1.05 0.00 46.50 61 30
6 30.42 28.57 1.23 0.00 43.00 40 30
7 29.49 27.06 1.16 0.00 43.17 62 30
8 33.36 34.99 1.92 13.50 103.50 58 30
9 29.00 25.92 1.03 0.00 39.75 73 30
10 26.75 22.60 1.66 0.00 40.50 49 30
11 30.55 27.68 1.21 0.00 41.67 66 31
12 30.75 27.01 1.62 0.00 43.17 55 31
13 35.50 32.12 1.46 0.00 52.75 69 32
14 26.00 25.02 1.83 0.00 45.75 51 32
15 33.50 27.88 1.63 0.00 53.00 74 32

Source: FFCS (2004–2005).

Note: the original measurement is in half hour units.

Table 3. Socially grounded number of child care hours (CCH) per household in an average month, according to the age of the youngest child and the number of children in the household.
age youngestchild number of children < 13 1 2 3 4+ Total
< 3 Proportion with children under 13 14% 14% 5% 2% 36%
CCH, based on 42.5 hours workweek 180 301 375 534 275
>= 3 Proportion with children under 13 37% 22% 4% 1% 64%
CCH, based on 42.5 hours workweek 89 179 256 379 136
Total Proportion with children under 13 51% 36% 10% 3% 100%
CCH, based on 42.5 hours workweek 114 226 322 476 185

Source: own calculations on the basis of SILC 2004.

Table 4. Average equivalent household income per individual in the baseline and the alternative scenario for various age groups and family types.
Categories Baseline Alternative
Amount Amount % increase
Overall 16,336 16,402 0.41%
Age groups Children (0–17) 15,765 16,340 3.64%
0–3 16,379 17,490 6.78%
4–12 16,125 16,848 4.49%
13–17 14,695 14,647 -0.32%
Adults (18–64) 17,311 17,304 -0.04%
Elderly (65 + ) 13,257 12,904 -2.66%
Family types With children and no MQ 17,616 18,503 5.04%
With children and with MQ 13,343 13,563 1.65%
No childrenand no MQ 17,526 17,495 -0.18%
No children and with MQ 13,918 13,057 -6.18%

Source: MISIM.

Table 5. Change of disposable equivalent income, split for tax increase and equivalent Euro and in percentage of baseline disposable equivalent income.
quintiles disposable equivalent income net change tax increase parental subsidy
baseline alternative Δ % Δ % Δ %
1 8,156 8,210 54 1.03 271 2.88 337 4.35
2 12,374 12,313 -61 -0.52 434 3.54 386 3.12
3 15,392 15,427 36 0.18 357 2.36 393 2.54
4 18,933 19,099 166 0.88 257 1.36 423 2.24
5 26,827 26,963 116 0.46 185 0.72 301 1.18
Total 16,336 16,402 62 0.41 301 2.17 368 2.69

Source: MISIM.

Table 6. Gainers and losers, average gain per gainer and average loss per loser, in equivalent Euros and in percentage of baseline disposable equivalent income.
quintiles % gainers % losers % unaffected average gain/gainer in disp. eq. inc. average loss / loser in disp. eq. inc.
Δ % Δ %
1 26.20 31.97 41.84 910 11.51 -577 -6.22
2 29.62 41.87 28.52 823 6.64 -727 -5.93
3 35.55 41.12 23.33 809 5.21 -612 -4.06
4 40.31 33.33 26.36 870 4.62 -555 -2.95
5 30.13 24.70 45.17 823 3.24 -535 -2.09
Total 32.36 34.60 33.04 847 6.24 -601 -4.25

Source: MISIM.

Table 7. Gainers and losers, average gain per gainer and average loss per loser, in equivalent Euros and in percentage of disposable equivalent income, for the 4 family types.
quintile s With children and no MQ With children and with MQ No children and no MQ No children and with MQ
% gainer
% losers
% unaffected
average gain/gainer or loss/loser % gainer
% losers
% unaffected
average gain/gainer or loss/loser % gainer
% losers
% unaffected
average gain/gainer or loss/loser % gainer
% losers
% unaffected
average gain/gainer or loss/loser
Δ % Δ % Δ % Δ %
1 97% 1064 13.32 59% 639 8.32 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00
0% 0 0.00 39% -394 -4.50 13% -171 -2.08 72% -721 -7.65
2 3% 0 0.00 2% 0 0.00 87% 0 0.00 28% 0 0.00
97% 890 7.19 65% 749 6.04 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00
0% 0 0.00 34% -427 -3.45 27% -155 -1.24 95% -1033 -8.45
3 3% 0 0.00 1% 0 0.00 73% 0 0.00 5% 0 0.00
100% 866 5.55 55% 585 3.86 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00
0% 0 0.00 45% -536 -3.62 39% -126 -0.82 99% -977 -6.47
4 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00 61% 0 0.00 1% 0 0.00
100% 898 4.77 54% 562 2.96 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00
0% 0 0.00 46% -562 -2.92 39% -133 -0.70 98% -1054 -5.61
5 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00 61% 0 0.00 2% 0 0.00
100% 831 3.28 44% 600 2.07 0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00
0% 0 0.00 56% -561 -2.11 24% -114 -0.47 100% -1,193 -4.65
0% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00 76% 0 0.00 0% 0 0.00

Source: MISIM.

Table 8. Average net change in yearly disposable equivalent income and in percentage of baseline disposable equivalent income for various age groups.
quintiles 0 to 12 13 to 18 19 to 34 35 to 49 50 to 64 65 to 74 75+ Total
1 849 -80 211 -2 -211 -259 -207 54
10.61 -0.62 2.79 0.37 -2.25 -2.54 -2.09 1.03
2 750 -1 38 1 39 -33 -469 -500 -355 -61
6.05 -1.13 1.11 -0.30 -3.83 -4.07 -2.92 -0.52
3 788 -1 1 1 1 50 46 -424 -443 -454 36
5.06 -0.76 0.92 0.25 -2.81 -2.89 -3.00 0.18
4 880 76 196 204 -437 -324 -377 1 66
4.69 0.44 1.02 1.10 -2.32 -1.75 -2.02 0.88
5 860 85 82 1 86 -280 -303 -265 116
3.38 0.35 0.34 0.70 -1.06 -1.24 -1.10 0.46
Total 824 -55 151 96 -358 -378 -319 62
5.90 -0.48 1.12 0.48 -2.37 -2.90 -2.45 0.41

Source: MISIM.

Table 9. Poverty rates with confidence intervals (*) by age group.
Baseline Alternative
Categories Population share Poverty Rate S.E. C.I. (95%) Poverty Rate S.E. C.I. (95%)
Overall 100% 11.71 0.68 10.37 13.05 12.19 0.65 10.90 13.47
Children (0–17) 22% 10.08 1.05 8.01 12.16 8.60 0.94 6.75 10.45
0-3 4% 12.22 1.90 8.47 15.97 7.10 1.49 4.16 10.03
4–12 12% 7.99 0.96 6.10 9.88 5.97 0.80 4.40 7.54
13–17 6% 12.66 1.74 9.24 16.08 14.50 1.80 10.96 18.05
Adults (18–64) 62% 10.22 0.70 8.85 11.59 10.79 0.69 9.43 12.16
Elderly (65+) 16% 19.94 1.27 17.43 22.45 22.74 1.38 20.02 25.47

Source: MISIM.

(*) Confidence intervals are based on a Taylor-linearized variance estimation (Greene, 2000).

Table 10. Poverty rates with confidence intervals (*) for 4 family types by the presence of children and use of marital quotient system.
Baseline Alternative
Categories Population share Poverty Rate S.E. C.I. (95%) Poverty Rate S.E. C.I. (95%)
Overall 100% 11.71 0.68 10.37 13.05 12.19 0.65 10.90 13.47
With children and no MQ 26% 7.02 0.95 5.15 8.89 4.25 0.73 2.83 5.68
With children and with MQ 12% 13.61 1.97 9.73 17.50 13.37 2.05 9.33 17.41
No children and no MQ 43% 11.60 0.75 10.12 13.07 11.70 0.76 10.22 13.19
No children and with MQ 20% 16.82 1.30 14.27 19.37 22.61 1.42 19.81 25.42

Source: MISIM.

(*) Confidence intervals are based on a Taylor-linearized variance estimation.

Table 11. Inequalit measures.
Baseline Alternative
S.E. C.I. (95%) S.E. C.I. (95%)
Gini 0.2294 0.0032 0.2231 0.2356 0.2321 0.0031 0.2261 0.2381
GE(-1) 0.1684 0.0113 0.1462 0.1907 0.1695 0.0113 0.1475 0.1916
MLD 0.1014 0.0035 0.0946 0.1082 0.1029 0.0034 0.0963 0.1095
Theil 0.0887 0.0026 0.0836 0.0937 0.0902 0.0025 0.0853 0.0951
GE(2) 0.0918 0.0030 0.0860 0.0976 0.0934 0.0029 0.0876 0.0991
GE(3) 0.1076 0.0046 0.0986 0.1166 0.1093 0.0046 0.1003 0.1183

Source: MISIM.

Confidence intervals are based on a Taylor-linearized variance estimation.

Table 12. Within group and between group inequality (MLD16) under baseline and alternative scenario for various age groups and family types.
Categories Baseline Alternative
Within Between Within %Δ Between %Δ
Overall 0.1014 0.1028 1.36%
Age groups 0.0968 0.00462 0.0973 0.50% 0.00558 21.21%
 Children (0-17) 0.0702 0.0678 -3.38%
  0-3 0.0796 0.0681 -14.48%
  4-12 0.0664 0.0620 -6.70%
  13-17 0.0678 0.0705 4.03%
 Adults (18–64) 0.1101 0.1117 1.51%
 Elderly (65+) 0.0827 0.0843 1.98%
Family types 0.0949 0.00651 0.0932 -1.78% 0.00967 48.54%
 With children and no MQ 0.0670 0.0593 -11.61%
 With children and with MQ 0.0545 0.0518 -4.90%
 No children and no MQ 0.1316 0.1321 0.41%
 No children and with MQ 0.0758 0.0777 2.49%

Source: MISIM.

Table A13. The use of centre-based childcare in Flanders: a comparison of sources.
SILC (use/hours) FFCS (use) FFCS (hours)
None 95.0 % 91.0% 83.8 %
For one child 4.5 % 8.1% 13.8 %
For two children 0.3 % 0.7% 2.3 %
For three children 0.3 % 0.3% 0.2 %
N 684 1577 394
Indicator of use is Types of childcare Types of childcare Hours of effective
based on: services used in a ‘normal’ week services used in a ‘normal’ week use in the observation week

Notes: all figures refer to families with any children < 13 in the region of Flanders SILC data are from 2004, FFCS from the school year 2004–2005 Data are weighted to correct for selective non-response.

Table A14. Types of childcare services used by Flemish families in a normal week.
FFCS SILC
Centre based care (crèche) 9.0% 5.0%
Childminder 11.79% 8.8%
Centre based care before and after school hours (other than school) 7.8% 0.9%
School care outside of school hours 17.6% 17.6%
Informal (grandparents and other) 30.2% 21.8%
Internate 0.3% 0.3%
Childminder at home under activation programme (‘PWA’) 2.8% 0.2%
Number of observations 1577 684

Notes: all figures refer to families with any children < 13 in the region of Flanders SILC data are from 2004, FFCS from the school year 2004–2005 Data are weighted to correct for selective non-response.