Building a microsimulation model of heroin use careers in Australia
Alison Ritter, Nagesh Shukla, Marian Shanahan, Phuong Van Hoang, Vu Lam Cao, Pascal Perez, Michael Farrell
Drug Policy Modelling Program, National Drug and Alcohol Research Centre, University of New South Wales, Australia; SMART Infrastructure Facility, University of Wollongong, Australia
Cite as: A. Ritter, N. Shukla, M. Shanahan, P. Van Hoang, V. Cao, P. Perez, M. Farrell; 2016; Building a microsimulation model of heroin use careers in Australia; International Journal of Microsimulation; 9(3); 140–176. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00146
Abstract
Illicit heroin use is a worldwide problem, with significant health and social costs. Treatment is known to be effective in changing heroin use habits, but it often needs to be provided over a lifetime, with people cycling in and out of treatment. It is therefore important to capture a long-term perspective on heroin use careers. The aim of this project was to build a lifetime microsimulation model of heroin using careers. This paper describes the conceptual logic of the model, the input parameters and the verification and validation results. A microsimulation model was chosen as the most appropriate simulation platform with 9 states, and 111,400 individuals (aged between 18 and 60) each with gender, HIV (human immunodeficiency virus) and HCV (hepatitis C) status, and treatment history. Probabilities associated with crime commission and individually calculated lengths of stay in each state were determined from multiple datasets. The model included costs associated with treatment provision, healthcare services, criminal activity, life years lost, and family benefit of treatment. The final model represented 42 years of a heroin use career for a cohort based on Australian (New South Wales) data. Individuals cycle into and out of heroin using states (including abstinence), as well as treatment and prison states. We were able to build a stable, tractable model and verified all parameters. Validation against external data sources revealed high validity. While there are limitations associated with any model, the heroin career model now has the potential to be used for simulations of alternate policy scenarios.
This article contains 14 tables.
Tables
Table 1.
State
Definition
Abstinence (S1)
Individuals in this state are not using heroin but have used heroin at some previous time.
Irregular use (S2)
Individuals in this state use heroin irregularly, as defined as 1 to 3 days a month, or a maximum of 1 or 2 days a week. They do not ever develop dependence.
Regular/dependent heroin use (S3)
Individuals in this state use heroin regularly (defined as more than 3 days per week in the last month) and they are not in receipt of any type of treatment.
Withdrawal (S4)
Individuals in this state receive withdrawal treatment for their heroin dependence. Withdrawal treatment is concerned with neuro-adaptation reversal, involves about 5–7 days care (in an inpatient or outpatient setting) and includes medications to manage symptoms, supportive care and case management. In this model it is characterised as residential withdrawal (for the purposes of unit costing), and excludes long-tern tapered methadone withdrawal.
Residential rehabilitation (RR) (S5)
Individuals in this state receive residential rehabilitation for their heroin dependence. RR is concerned with behavioural change across all life areas, including relapse prevention, psychological wellbeing, physical health, nutrition etc. It is provided in residential settings, and an ideal treatment program is 6–9 months long although many will leave in the first week. While some RR in Australia also provide OST as part of the program, as characterised here this RR does not include OST.
Opioid Substitution Treatment (OST) (S6)
Individuals in this state receive Opioid Substitution Treatment for their heroin dependence. The provision of a legal, safe opioid (either methadone or buprenorphine), dispensed daily or less frequently with take-away doses; requires a prescriber and attendance at a pharmacy (primary care or clinic settings). The model does not distinguish between methadone and buprenorphine.
Counselling Only (S7)
Individuals in this state receive counselling for their heroin dependence. Provision of psychological therapy only, on an outpatient basis (weekly or fortnightly) with case management.
In-prison no treatment (S8)
Individuals in this state are in prison; and have a history of heroin use.
In-prison treatment (OST) (S9)
Individuals in this state are in prison, have a history of heroin use, and are in receipt of OST in prison.
All LOS determined by crime type (probability) and then the average sentence for that crime type (BOCSAR Court Data Report, 2012, see NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research. http://www.bocsar.nsw.gov.au).