Consumption, Savings and Wealth Dynamic microsimulation

Research articles · Dec 31, 2023

The Cost of Basic Income in the United Kingdom: A Microsimulation Analysis

Karl Widerquist, Georg Arndt

Georgetown University-Qatar, Doha, Qatar; Independent Scholar

Volume 16(3) Winter 2023

Cite as: K. Widerquist, G. Arndt; 2023; The Cost of Basic Income in the United Kingdom: A Microsimulation Analysis; International Journal of Microsimulation; 16(3); 1–18. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00286

Abstract

This article uses microsimulation analysis to estimate that the net cost (the real cost) of a roughly poverty-level Universal Basic Income (UBI) for the United Kingdom is about £45 billion per year or 2% of GDP. We use 2019/2020 fiscal year data to examine a scheme with a UBI of £8,040 for adults and £4,020 for children with a marginal tax rate of 50% on net beneficiaries. This UBI scheme adds only 25% to the cost of the UK’s existing transfer system and only 5.1% to total UK government spending. About 54% of UK families would benefit from the transition to this UBI scheme, with the average gain for each net-beneficiary family being £3,025. The £45 billion figure is a “net” cost in two senses. First, it subtracts the amount of UBI that individuals pay themselves as they simultaneously receive UBI and pay higher taxes to finance it. This calculation alone shows that the cost of UBI is only about one-third of the often-quoted-but-not-very-useful concept of “gross cost,” which ignores the fact that it costs nothing for a person to give themselves a pound; neither does giving oneself a pound affect any marginal cost or benefits faced by any person’s budget constraint. Second, this article also adds and subtracts the costs and savings involved in integrating the UBI scheme into the UK’s existing tax and benefit system. This calculation further reduces the scheme’s cost to 10% of gross cost. Under this scheme, the percent of UK families with incomes below the current official poverty line would drop by 72% from 17.9% to 5.0%. The largest increase in incomes would be felt by those most deeply in poverty, so that deep poverty, poverty among children, and poverty among the elderly would all but disappear.

This article contains 5 tables.

Tables

Table 1. UBI, poverty line, and break-even points for different household compositions
Family CompositionUBIPoverty LineBreak-even point
Single Individual8,04010,77416,081
1 Adult, 1 Child12,06113,99024,121
Couple16,08116,08132,162
Average Family (1.88 adults, 0.51 children)17,16617,08434,333
2 Adults, 1 Child20,10119,29740,202
2 Adults, 2 Children24,12122,51348,243
Table 2. Descriptive Statistics of the UK §
Total population66.8 millionONS (2021, p1)
Share of people aged 65 or older19%ONS (2021, p11)
Share of people aged under 1619%ONS (2021, p11)
Total GDP£2,255 billion*ONS (2023a)
GDP per capita£33,443 per year†ONS (2023b)
Total Government expenditure£881 billion (39% of GDP)HMT (2020, p36)
Government spending on social security ‡£275 billion (12% of GDP)HMT (2020, p76)
...of which direct benefit spending£191 billion (8% of GDP)DWP (2020, p10)

https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/timeseries/bktl/pn2#othertimeseries.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/grossdomesticproductgdp/timeseries/ihxw/pn2

Includes e.g. tax credits in addition to direct benefit spending.

Office for National Statistics (2018c)

Table 3. List of UK Social Security Programs; programs in italics are retained under UBI scheme
MTBContributoryNon-MTB; Non-Contributory
Income SupportJob Seeker’s AllowanceChild Benefit
Jobseeker’s AllowanceEmployment and Support AllowanceAttendance Allowance
Employment and Support Allowance (income-based part)Retirement PensionDisability Living Allowance
Pension CreditBereavement BenefitPersonal Independence Payment
Housing Benefit, Local Housing Allowance*Maternity AllowanceSevere Disablement Allowance
Council Tax BenefitCarer’s Allowance
Working Tax CreditIndustrial Injuries Disablement Benefit
Child Tax CreditGuardian’s Allowance
Social FundWar Pensions
Universal CreditWinter Fuel Allowance

Over the past few years, the UK has sought to consolidate many of its social security programmes, rolling them into Universal Credit. This transition is still ongoing. One component of Universal Credit is Housing Benefits. To accurately estimate the costs of retaining housing benefits, we are treating all eligible households in UKMOD as if they would still receive stand-alone Housing Benefits. While this treatment is not entirely accurate, it should not impact the bottom line in any relevant way, given that the payments for housing under Universal Credit are comparable to the previously stand-alone programme.

Table 4. Final Cost for Different Ways of Integrating UBI into Existing Social Spending
Cost ItemCost in billionsPercent of GDP
1.UBI in a vacuum1396.2%
2.Existing benefits system (in TBM)2079.2%
3.Full-replacement UBI (line 1-2)-68-3.0%
4.Cost of UBI and existing benefits without replacement (1+2)34615.4%
5.“Replaceable” benefits (RB)1305.7%
6.Hold-harmless (HH) benefits and UBI (1-5)100.4%
7.Total cost of remaining (HH benefits) and UBI (6+2)2179.6%
8.Tax replacement (TR)351.6%
9.Fully integrated HH benefit system including UBI (7+8)25211.2%
10.Total net cost of integrated UBI (6+8 or 9-2)452.0%
Table 5. Disposable Income for Households for Different Income Ranges Before and After UBI is introduced
Market Income rangeNumber of HouseholdsDisposable Income in Status Quo (including benefits)Disposable Income with UBI (including benefits)Difference
05,000353,3873,07411,7508,677
5,00110,0001,534,7178,10211,8713,769
10,00115,0002,938,70512,77815,2212,442
15,00120,0003,486,67917,51319,8832,370
20,00125,0003,277,65322,40024,9762,577
25,00130,0002,828,91727,36530,7693,404
30,00135,0002,525,04132,41935,9443,525
35,00140,0002,176,33737,43941,1463,706