Cite as: E. Toder; 2024; The Use of Microsimulation Models to Inform US Tax Policymaking; International Journal of Microsimulation; 17(3); 1–20. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00314
This article contains 6 tables.
Tables
Table 1. Divided Power in US Political System.
Federal
State
Local
Executive Branch
President/Independent Agencies
Governors
Mayors/City Managers
Legislative Branch
House and Senate
Upper and Lower Houses (mostly)
City Councils and other
Judicial Branch
US Supreme Court and District Courts
State Courts
Local Courts
Major Fiscal Responsibilities
Defense and Foreign Policy, Health, and Retirement Benefit Programs, Other
Most Public Services (Education, Prisons, Police, Roads etc.)
Public Services as Delegated by States
Major Sources of Revenue
Individual Income Tax, Payroll Tax, Corporate Income Tax
Income and Sales Taxes
Mostly Local Property Taxes
Table 2. Who Supplies Data and Estimates for Federal Agencies.
Data
For Congress
For Executive Branch
Baseline Economic Forecast
Congressional Budget Office
Treasury/Office of Management and Budget/Council of Economic Advisors
Baseline Receipts
Congressional Budget Office
Treasury
Revenue Effects of Legislation
Joint Tax Committee
Treasury
Spending Effects of Legislation
Congressional Budget Office
Office of Management and Budget/Program Agencies
Tax Expenditures
Joint Tax Committee
Treasury
Distributional Estimates
Congressional Budget Office/Joint Tax Committee
Treasury
Macroeconomic Effects of Tax Legislation
Joint Tax Committee/Congressional Budget Office
Council of Economic Advisors
Table 3. Types of Models Used in Tax Policy Analysis.
Type of Model
Intended Use
Data Sources
Static Microsimulation Models
Estimating effects on receipts and income distribution of changes in individual income and payroll taxes
Samples of Individual Tax Returns Produced by Internal Revenue Service, augmented by survey data from US Census Bureau (Current Population Survey), Federal Reserve Board (Survey of Consumer Finances), Bureau of Labor Statistics (Consumer Expenditure Survey) and other agencies
General equilibrium and growth models with full employment
Estimates of long-term effects on output of major tax policy changes by government agencies and academic economists
National Income Data Produced by US Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis and selected summary data from Internal Revenue Service, Statistics of Income Division
Keynesian growth models
Estimates of short-term effect of tax policy changes on GDP, the rate of inflation and other macro-economic aggregates
National Income Data produced by US Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis and selected summary data from Internal Revenue Service, Statistics of Income Division
Sectoral Models
Estimates of effects on selected markets, including markets for energy, health care, housing, and other assets.
Current Population Survey, National Income and Product Accounts and specialized data sets produced by US Energy Information Administration, US Department of Health and Human Services, and other agencies
Table 4. Estimated Budgetary Effects of 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (in billions of dollars).
Change in Budget Surplus
Fiscal Years 2018-27
Fiscal Year 2027
Individual and Estate Taxes (Including the Qualified Business Income Deduction)