Cite as: G. Dekkers; 2007; The financial implications of working longer: An application of a micro-economic model of retirement in Belgium; International Journal of Microsimulation; 1(1); 10–25. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00003
Abstract
In this paper, the costs and benefits associated with postponing retirement are simulated in a standard simulation model for Belgium, using the approach of Stock and Wise (1990). Unlike earlier microsimulation-based applications of this approach, such as Gruber and Wise (1999, 2004), this model does not take a representative sample as the point of departure, but simulates the costs and benefits of postponing retirement for four fictitious employees, representing male and female white- and blue-collar workers. While confirming conclusions drawn by other authors, this model allows for the separation of specific retirement schemes, and of the effect of different fiscal regimes for those retired and working. It is shown that differences between retirement schemes show up in differences in replacement rates and by whether or not the retirement benefit is a function of career length. Furthermore, advantageous fiscal regulations for the retired have a strong impact on the implicit costs of postponing retirement.
This article contains 4 figures and 11 tables.
Figures
Figure 1. Activity rate of 55–65 year olds, and effective retirement age in Europe (European Community, 2003: 42–48).Figure 2. The structure of the micro-economic pension model.Figure A1. Wage per day for the categories of workers as a whole.Figure A2. Logarithm of the gross wage per day as a function of age.
Tables
t
the year of potential retirement
r
the year of actual retirement
s
future year, starting from either t or r
ys
labour income or salary in year s
bs(r)
pension income in year s, given retirement in r
Uy
the utility of consumption
Ub
the utility of leisure
β
discount factor = 1/(1+discount rate)
as
the probability of survival from t to s
Table 1. Pension benefit for a single male white-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
60
2000
40
47,811
15,763
0.330
0.519
59,255
−28,838
.
.
.
61
2001
41
49,534
16,600
0.335
0.522
42918
−23,449
−5,390
17,216
0.238
62
2002
42
50,758
17,512
0.345
0.529
27,929
−16,110
−7,339
14,984
0.329
63
2003
43
51,565
18,193
0.353
0.537
13,094
−8,680
−7,429
14,454
0.340
64
2004
44
52,512
18,856
0.359
0.543
0
0
−8,680
12,591
0.408
Table 2. Pension benefit for a single female white-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
60
2000
40
26,260
11,402
0.434
0.683
31,744
−23,272
.
.
.
61
2001
41
27,171
12,057
0.444
0.690
21,256
−20,234
−3,039
11000
0.216
62
2002
42
27,733
12,801
0.462
0.704
12,324
−15,236
−4,998
8,844
0.361
63
2003
43
28,193
13,029
0.462
0.702
6,461
−7,280
−7,956
5,712
0.582
64
2004
44
28,664
13,409
0.468
0.708
0
0
−7,280
6,098
0.544
Table 3. Pension benefit for a single male blue-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
60
2000
40
22,541
10,833
0.481
0.734
23,179
−24,162
.
.
.
61
2001
41
23,205
11,365
0.490
0.748
15,894
−19,531
−4,631
7,678
0.376
62
2002
42
23,489
11,963
0.509
0.768
10,245
−13,093
−6,438
5,536
0.538
63
2003
43
23,832
12,395
0.520
0.771
4,972
−6,662
−6,431
5,296
0.548
64
2004
44
24,128
12,840
0.532
0.790
0
0
662
4,690
0.587
Table 4. Pension benefit for a single female blue-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
60
2000
40
13,662
8,187
0.599
0.785
19,236
−13,706
.
.
.
61
2001
41
14,056
8,856
0.630
0.828
9,189
−15,512
1,806
10,302
−0.213
62
2002
42
14,285
9,438
0.661
0.861
4,466
−11,856
−3,656
4,642
0.441
63
2003
43
14,475
9,438
0.652
0.831
6,707
−1,405
−10,451
−2,299
1.282
64
2004
44
14,682
9,992
0.681
0.873
0
0
−1,405
6,563
0.176
Table 5. CELS benefit for a single male white-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross CELS benefit
gross future pension benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
58
1998
38
44,546
24,138
18,856
0.542
0.708
52,268
−74,371
.
.
.
59
1999
39
45,680
24,704
18,856
0.541
0.704
46,317
−59,835
−14,536
6,366
0.696
60
2000
40
47,811
25,773
18,856
0.539
0.699
38,397
−47,241
−12,593
8,331
0.602
61
2001
41
49,534
26,646
18,856
0.538
0.696
28,432
−35,566
−11,676
9234
0.558
62
2002
42
50,758
27,317
18,856
0.538
0.694
19,486
−22,632
−12,933
7,715
0.626
63
2003
43
51,565
27,794
18,856
0.539
0.694
10,414
−10,276
−12,356
7,886
0.610
64
2004
44
52,512
28,527
18,856
0.543
0.698
0
0
−10,276
9,400
0.522
Table 6. CELS benefit for a single female white-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross CELS benefit
gross future pension benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
58
1998
38
24,864
14,296
13,348
0.575
0.807
26,046
−53,426
.
.
.
59
1999
39
25,360
14,545
13,371
0.574
0.802
23,575
−42,988
−10,438
2,677
0.796
60
2000
40
26,260
14,998
13,401
0.571
0.797
19,485
−34,200
−8,787
4290
0.672
61
2001
41
27,171
15,464
13,411
0.569
0.792
14,065
−36,355
−7,946
5,163
0.606
62
2002
42
27,733
15,804
13,413
0.570
0.791
9,698
−16,871
−9,384
3,541
0.726
63
2003
43
28,193
16,108
13,413
0.571
0.792
4,787
−8,420
−8,451
4,312
0.662
64
2004
44
28,664
16,603
13,405
0.579
0.800
0
0
−8,420
4,072
0.674
Table 7. CELS benefit for a single male blue-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross CELS benefit
gross future pension benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
58
1998
38
21,883
13,377
12,851
0.611
0.855
16,070
−52,090
.
.
.
59
1999
39
22,113
13,445
12,852
0.608
0.851
14,868
−41,673
−10,417
1,297
0.889
60
2000
40
22,541
13,707
12,851
0.608
0.850
12,369
−32,815
−8,858
2,618
0.772
61
2001
41
23,205
13,971
12,852
0.602
0.843
8,913
−24,901
−7,914
3,472
0.695
62
2002
42
23,489
14,266
12,846
0.607
0.846
6,104
−15,992
−8,909
2,166
0.804
63
2003
43
23,832
14,613
12,844
0.613
0.848
3,054
−7,985
−8,007
2,841
0.738
64
2004
44
24,128
15,243
12,840
0.632
0.866
0
0
−7,985
2,516
0.760
Table 8. CELS benefit for a single female blue-collar worker.
age
year
career length
gross wage
gross CELS benefit
gross future pension benefit
gross replacement rate
net replacement rate
net option value (€)
net peak value (€)
net ∆SSW
net PR
net itax
58
1998
38
13,155
9,624
9,992
0.732
0.938
0
0
.
.
.
59
1999
39
13,564
9,878
9,992
0.728
0.943
516
8,497
−8,497
−332
1.041
60
2000
40
13,662
9,966
9,992
0.729
0.941
971
17,026
−8,529
−562
1.071
61
2001
41
14,056
10,256
9,992
0.730
0.941
833
24,669
−7,643
290
0.964
62
2002
42
14,285
10,474
9,992
0.733
0.934
2,199
34,208
−9,539
−1,791
1.231
63
2003
43
14,475
10,693
9,992
0.739
0.925
3,488
43,365
−9,157
−1,545
1.203
64
2004
44
14,682
10,843
9,992
0.739
0.925
2,414
50,034
−6,669
771
0.896
Table 9. Simulation variants: average pension and CELS benefits over all choice years r
Net benefits (after taxes and social contributions)
Gross benefits (before taxes and social contributions)
With partner without income of his or her own (section 6.3.2)
Pension benefit
Rep. ratio
0.645
0.731
0.775
0.900
0.763
0.430
0.567
0.633
0.805
0.609
∆SSW
16,213
−10,912
−9,498
−4,429
−11,845
−8,486
−8,611
−4,257
PR
9,534
6,036
5,301
5,318
34,229
17,102
12,735
8,909
Itax
0.650
0.677
0.663
0.476
0.617
0.258
0.335
0.406
0.329
0.332
CELS benefit
Rep. ratio
0.764
0.798
0.811
0.853
0.806
0.577
0.640
0.688
0.796
0.675
∆SSW
−19,372
−14,634
−13,257
−10,021
−23,646
−15,059
−14,190
−10,118
PR
4,781
1,507
951
−650
19,463
9,041
5,994
2,389
Itax
0.816
0.925
0.950
1.075
0.941
0.548
0.625
0.703
0.810
0.672
Single, after a five-year shorter career (Section 6.3.3)
Pension benefit
Rep. ratio
0.511
0.652
0.698
0.731
0.648
0.326
0.420
0.467
0.571
0.446
∆SSW
−6,766
−4,787
−5,453
−1,969
−8,490
−4,977
−6,037
−1,690
PR
15,255
8,944
6,387
6,259
37,584
20,611
15,309
11,476
Itax
0.309
0.350
0.463
0.241
0.341
0.185
0.196
0.284
0.130
0.199
Table 10. The effect of technical variants on the cost of postponing retirement: simulation variants for single workers: Averages over all choice years r.
Net benefits (after taxes and social contributions
Gross benefits (before taxes and social contributions)
white-collar
blue-collar
white-collar
blue-collar
male
female
male
female
x̅
male
female
male
female
x̅
Variant 1: Increase career length required for full pension entitlement (section 6.4.3.1)