Taxes and benefits

Research articles · Dec 31, 2012

A microsimulation approach to an optimal Swedish income tax

Peter Ericson, Lennart Flood

Empirica, Högbergsgatan 50, Sweden; School of Business, Economics and Law, University of Gothenburg, Department of Economics, Sweden

Volume 5(2) Autumn 2012

Cite as: P. Ericson, L. Flood; 2012; A microsimulation approach to an optimal Swedish income tax; International Journal of Microsimulation; 5(2); 2–21. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00069

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to identify a Swedish tax/benefit design that maximizes social welfare. A two stage process is proposed where individuals’ preferred choice of leisure and consumption is solved in the first stage, and the second stage identifies the tax/benefit system that maximizes the social welfare function. The study deviates from the mainstream literature as the first stage is based on a micro simulation model with estimated behavioural responses. We estimate a structural model for a sample of workers or voluntary non-workers that describes heterogeneity in consumption-leisure preferences for different household types. Models that describe the participation decision for the unemployed as well as individuals outside the labour force are also included. The results suggest that increased housing allowance, basic deduction, and in-work tax credit in combination with a reduction of the progressive national taxes would increase welfare.

This article contains 3 figures and 6 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Structure of SWEtaxben.
Figure 2. The Swedish income tax in 2006.
Figure 3. The optimal tax profiles compared to the base year 2009.

Tables

Table 1.
Household Single mothers Single Single
Wage increase by 1% Male Female Female Female Male
Male 0.10 −0.07 0.05
Female 0 0.16 0.21 0.38
Table 2.
W1 (Bonferroni) W2 (Gini) W3 W∞ (Utilitarian)
p(.01)/p(.5) 6.64 1.98 1.33 1
p(.05)/p(.5) 4.32 1.90 1.33 1
p(.30)/p(.5) 1.74 1.40 1.21 1
p(.95)/p(.5) 0.07 0.10 0.13 1
Table 3.
Estimates Standard Errors
Log leisure, βl 3.0985 0.0215
Log leisure squared, βll 0.3620 0.0151
Log income, βC 4.7262 0.0224
Log income squared, βCC −0.0616 0.0089
Table 4. Flat tax.
Reform Description Hours Participation Budget Disposable income Labor income Income tax GINI D9/D2
0 Base 2006 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.0% 2.34
1 20% 4.78% 1.55% −10.28% 17.35% 4.88% −30.93% 8.2% 2.84
2 21% 4.60% 1.44% −9.13% 15.99% 4.72% −27.99% 8.3% 2.81
3 22% 4.41% 1.34% −7.98% 14.62% 4.55% −25.07% 8.5% 2.77
4 23% 4.18% 1.21% −6.86% 13.23% 4.36% −22.16% 8.6% 2.74
5 24% 3.95% 1.09% −5.75% 11.86% 4.16% −19.26% 8.8% 2.70
6 25% 3.69% 0.95% −4.66% 10.47% 3.95% −16.39% 9.0% 2.67
7 26% 3.43% 0.82% −3.57% 9.09% 3.73% −13.52% 9.2% 2.63
8 27% 3.18% 0.67% −2.50% 7.71% 3.51% −10.67% 9.4% 2.60
9 28% 2.89% 0.50% −1.44% 6.32% 3.27% −7.83% 9.7% 2.57
10 29% 2.61% 0.32% −0.40% 4.95% 3.04% −5.01% 9.9% 2.53
11 30% 2.29% 0.12% 0.61% 3.56% 2.77% −2.21% 10.1% 2.50
12 31% 1.98% −0.08% 1.64% 2.18% 2.51% 0.58% 10.4% 2.46
13 32% 1.67% −0.27% 2.64% 0.80% 2.24% 3.35% 10.6% 2.43
14 33% 1.32% −0.49% 3.61% −0.56% 1.96% 6.11% 10.9% 2.40
15 34% 0.95% −0.73% 4.55% −1.94% 1.65% 8.83% 11.2% 2.36
16 35% 0.60% −0.95% 5.52% −3.30% 1.38% 11.56% 11.4% 2.33
Table 5. Age-dependent taxes.
Reform Flat tax Up 26–46 (%) Down 46–65 (%) Hours Participation Budget Disposabl e-income Labor income Income tax GINI D9/D2
0 Base 2006 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.0% 2.34
1 15% 1.00 1.00 3.89% 1.11% −6.60% 12.46% 4.02% −21.12% 6.6% 2.68
2 15% 1.05 1.05 3.77% 1.05% −6.15% 11.87% 3.92% −19.93% 6.6% 2.67
3 15% 1.10 1.10 3.65% 0.98% −5.71% 11.28% 3.81% −18.74% 6.6% 2.65
4 15% 1.15 1.15 3.53% 0.92% −5.27% 10.70% 3.71% −17.56% 6.7% 2.63
5 15% 1.20 1.20 3.40% 0.85% −4.85% 10.10% 3.59% −16.39% 6.8% 2.62
6 15% 1.25 1.25 3.26% 0.77% −4.43% 9.51% 3.47% −15.23% 6.9% 2.60
7 15% 1.30 1.30 3.11% 0.68% −4.02% 8.91% 3.33% −14.08% 7.0% 2.59
8 15% 1.35 1.35 2.97% 0.60% −3.60% 8.33% 3.22% −12.92% 7.1% 2.57
9 15% 1.40 1.40 2.83% 0.52% −3.19% 7.74% 3.09% −11.77% 7.2% 2.56
10 15% 1.45 1.45 2.66% 0.42% −2.81% 7.14% 2.94% −10.65% 7.3% 2.54
11 15% 1.50 1.50 2.50% 0.32% −2.43% 6.55% 2.80% −9.52% 7.5% 2.52
12 15% 1.55 1.55 2.33% 0.21% −2.05% 5.96% 2.65% −8.41% 7.7% 2.51
13 15% 1.60 1.60 2.18% 0.13% −1.65% 5.38% 2.52% −7.27% 7.8% 2.49
14 15% 1.65 1.65 1.99% 0.00% −1.30% 4.78% 2.35% −6.19% 8.0% 2.48
15 15% 1.70 1.70 1.81% −0.12% −0.94% 4.19% 2.19% −5.09% 8.2% 2.47
16 15% 1.75 1.75 1.58% −0.27% −0.63% 3.58% 1.98% −4.05% 8.5% 2.45
17 15% 1.80 1.80 1.36% −0.43% −0.32% 2.98% 1.79% −3.00% 8.7% 2.44
18 15% 1.85 1.85 1.16% −0.56% 0.02% 2.39% 1.62% −1.94% 9.0% 2.42
19 15% 1.90 1.90 0.93% −0.72% 0.32% 1.80% 1.42% −0.90% 9.3% 2.42
20 15% 1.95 1.95 0.73% −0.85% 0.65% 1.22% 1.25% 0.15% 9.5% 2.40
21 15% 2.00 2.00 0.50% −1.00% 0.94% 0.63% 1.05% 1.16% 9.8% 2.39
22 Extended 2009 in-work tax credit 1.79% 1.52% −3.93% 5.76% 1.38% −11.55% −1.4% 2.48
Table 6. Combination of tax/benefits15.
Reform Top level Level Break point Housing allowance Credit/deduction Hours Participation Budget Disposable income Labor income Income tax GINI D9/D2 W1 W2 W3 W∞
0 0% 0% 0% 0% 2006 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.0% 2.34 80 80 80 76
39 0% -25% 25% 50% 2009 + age 2.69% 1.54% −4.85% 8.31% 2.49% −14.97% 1.6% 2.46 17 3 1 4
79 −100% −25% 25% 50% 2009 + age 2.74% 1.54% −4.85% 8.46% 2.58% −15.11% 2.1% 2.47 21 5 2 2
59 −100% 0% 25% 50% 2009 + age 2.54% 1.53% −4.76% 7.90% 2.27% −14.48% 0.9% 2.45 18 6 3 6
77 −100% −25% 25% 50% 2009 +50% 3.06% 1.91% −7.51% 11.40% 2.80% −21.75% 1.1% 2.47 12 7 5 21
19 0% 0% 25% 50% 2009 + age 2.49% 1.53% −4.76% 7.72% 2.16% −14.31% 0.3% 2.45 22 9 4 13
37 0% −25% 25% 50% 2009 +50% 3.03% 1.91% −7.48% 11.27% 2.73% −21.61% 0.7% 2.47 11 8 6 24
69 −100% −25% 0% 50% 2009 + age 2.18% 1.46% −4.47% 7.21% 2.00% −13.40% 1.0% 2.42 16 10 9 14
29 0% −25% 0% 50% 2009 + age 2.10% 1.46% −4.44% 6.96% 1.84% −13.14% 0.3% 2.42 13 11 12 18
78 −100% −25% 25% 50% 2009 +100% 3.52% 2.35% −10.60% 14.87% 3.11% −29.50% 0.1% 2.48 1 1 11 46
38 0% −25% 25% 50% 2009 +100% 3.49% 2.36% −10.57% 14.74% 3.05% −29.35% −0.3% 2.48 2 2 13 50
57 −100% 0% 25% 50% 2009 +50% 2.88% 1.90% −7.40% 10.87% 2.52% −21.14% −0.1% 2.45 15 16 16 31
67 −100% −25% 0% 50% 2009 +50% 2.55% 1.84% −7.12% 10.23% 2.27% −20.11% 0.0% 2.42 9 14 20 35
34 0% −25% 25% 0% 2009 + age 2.82% 1.64% −4.66% 8.29% 2.59% −14.92% 1.7% 2.47 51 22 7 3
58 −100% 0% 25% 50% 2009 +100% 3.36% 2.35% −10.48% 14.37% 2.87% −28.89% −1.0% 2.47 3 4 18 59
74 −100% −25% 25% 0% 2009 + age 2.86% 1.64% −4.67% 8.43% 2.68% −15.05% 2.1% 2.47 52 25 8 1
54 −100% 0% 25% 0% 2009 + age 2.66% 1.62% −4.58% 7.87% 2.37% −14.42% 0.9% 2.45 48 24 10 5
64 −100% −25% 0% 0% 2009 + age 2.32% 1.57% −4.27% 7.19% 2.11% −13.34% 1.0% 2.42 41 26 15 12
27 0% −25% 0% 50% 2009 +50% 2.47% 1.84% −7.10% 9.98% 2.12% −19.86% −0.7% 2.42 10 17 25 43
17 0% 0% 25% 50% 2009 +50% 2.82% 1.89% −7.41% 10.70% 2.40% −20.98% −0.6% 2.45 19 19 24 36
73 −100% −25% 25% 0% 2009 +100% 3.62% 2.43% −10.44% 14.84% 3.20% −29.47% 0.2% 2.48 25 18 19 39
24 0% −25% 0% 0% 2009 + age 2.23% 1.56% −4.25% 6.93% 1.96% −13.08% 0.3% 2.42 42 28 17 16
14 0% 0% 25% 0% 2009 + age 2.61% 1.63% −4.58% 7.70% 2.26% −14.26% 0.4% 2.45 54 30 14 10
49 −100% 0% 0% 50% 2009 + age 1.79% 1.44% −4.28% 6.27% 1.49% −12.28% −0.6% 2.39 23 23 32 32
36 0% −25% 25% 50% 2009 2.48% 1.30% −4.47% 7.75% 2.33% −13.82% 1.9% 2.46 37 38 26 11
76 −100% −25% 25% 50% 2009 2.52% 1.30% −4.47% 7.89% 2.42% −13.95% 2.3% 2.47 38 40 27 8
18 0% 0% 25% 50% 2009 +100% 3.31% 2.35% −10.48% 14.20% 2.75% −28.74% −1.4% 2.46 6 13 29 66
68 −100% −25% 0% 50% 2009 +100% 3.06% 2.30% −10.21% 13.76% 2.63% −27.93% −1.0% 2.44 4 12 30 68
33 0% −25% 25% 0% 2009 +100% 3.59% 2.43% −10.42% 14.71% 3.13% −29.32% −0.2% 2.48 26 20 23 48
72 −100% −25% 25% 0% 2009 +50% 3.19% 2.01% −7.33% 11.38% 2.90% −21.71% 1.1% 2.47 47 33 21 19
32 0% −25% 25% 0% 2009 +50% 3.16% 2.02% −7.30% 11.26% 2.84% −21.56% 0.7% 2.47 46 34 22 22
28 0% −25% 0% 50% 2009 +100% 2.98% 2.30% −10.17% 13.53% 2.50% −27.67% −1.6% 2.44 5 15 34 72
56 −100% 0% 25% 50% 2009 2.32% 1.29% −4.39% 7.34% 2.11% −13.32% 1.1% 2.45 36 43 31 17
9 0% 0% 0% 50% 2009 + age 1.69% 1.45% −4.25% 5.95% 1.30% −11.95% −1.4% 2.39 24 31 40 45
66 −100% −25% 0% 50% 2009 1.96% 1.22% −4.10% 6.65% 1.84% −12.25% 1.2% 2.42 32 45 39 26
52 −100% 0% 25% 0% 2009 +50% 3.01% 2.00% −7.22% 10.86% 2.63% −21.09% 0.0% 2.46 49 37 28 29
53 −100% 0% 25% 0% 2009 +100% 3.47% 2.43% −10.32% 14.35% 2.95% −28.86% −0.9% 2.47 28 27 33 56
16 0% 0% 25% 50% 2009 2.27% 1.29% −4.38% 7.16% 2.00% −13.16% 0.5% 2.45 39 48 35 23
47 −100% 0% 0% 50% 2009 +50% 2.18% 1.81% −6.95% 9.32% 1.77% −19.04% −1.5% 2.40 14 29 48 61
26 0% −25% 0% 50% 2009 1.87% 1.22% −4.07% 6.39% 1.68% −11.99% 0.5% 2.42 33 49 43 28
62 −100% −25% 0% 0% 2009 +50% 2.69% 1.95% −6.93% 10.21% 2.38% −20.06% 0.0% 2.43 44 41 36 34
48 −100% 0% 0% 50% 2009 +100% 2.72% 2.28% −10.03% 12.89% 2.17% −26.89% −2.4% 2.41 7 21 52 77
44 −100% 0% 0% 0% 2009 + age 1.92% 1.54% −4.09% 6.24% 1.60% −12.22% −0.6% 2.39 50 44 38 30
63 −100% −25% 0% 0% 2009 +100% 3.16% 2.38% −10.04% 13.73% 2.72% −27.90% −0.9% 2.44 27 32 44 65
31 0% −25% 25% 0% 2009 2.63% 1.42% −4.27% 7.73% 2.45% −13.75% 1.9% 2.47 61 58 41 9
22 0% −25% 0% 0% 2009 +50% 2.61% 1.95% −6.91% 9.97% 2.23% −19.81% −0.6% 2.42 45 46 42 41
13 0% 0% 25% 0% 2009 +100% 3.41% 2.42% −10.32% 14.17% 2.84% −28.70% −1.4% 2.47 31 35 45 64
12 0% 0% 25% 0% 2009 +50% 2.96% 2.00% −7.23% 10.68% 2.51% −20.93% −0.5% 2.45 56 50 37 33
71 −100% −25% 25% 0% 2009 2.67% 1.42% −4.27% 7.88% 2.54% −13.89% 2.3% 2.47 63 59 47 7
51 −100% 0% 25% 0% 2009 2.47% 1.41% −4.19% 7.32% 2.23% −13.26% 1.1% 2.45 59 57 46 15
7 0% 0% 0% 50% 2009 +50% 2.06% 1.81% −6.94% 9.00% 1.57% −18.74% −2.3% 2.39 20 39 56 71
23 0% −25% 0% 0% 2009 +100% 3.09% 2.38% −10.00% 13.50% 2.59% −27.63% −1.5% 2.44 30 36 51 70
46 −100% 0% 0% 50% 2009 1.56% 1.20% −3.92% 5.70% 1.32% −11.13% −0.4% 2.39 35 53 57 44
11 0% 0% 25% 0% 2009 2.42% 1.41% −4.19% 7.14% 2.11% −13.10% 0.6% 2.45 60 60 50 20
8 0% 0% 0% 50% 2009 +100% 2.61% 2.28% −10.02% 12.59% 1.97% −26.61% −3.2% 2.41 8 42 61 80
4 0% 0% 0% 0% 2009 + age 1.82% 1.55% −4.07% 5.92% 1.40% −11.90% −1.4% 2.39 55 51 49 37
61 −100% −25% 0% 0% 2009 2.12% 1.35% −3.89% 6.64% 1.96% −12.18% 1.2% 2.42 57 61 54 25
21 0% −25% 0% 0% 2009 2.03% 1.34% −3.86% 6.38% 1.81% −11.92% 0.5% 2.42 58 62 55 27
42 −100% 0% 0% 0% 2009 +50% 2.31% 1.91% −6.77% 9.29% 1.88% −19.00% −1.5% 2.40 43 52 53 58
43 −100% 0% 0% 0% 2009 +100% 2.83% 2.36% −9.86% 12.87% 2.27% −26.85% −2.3% 2.42 29 47 58 75
6 0% 0% 0% 50% 2009 1.47% 1.21% −3.89% 5.39% 1.14% −10.81% −1.2% 2.39 40 56 60 55
41 −100% 0% 0% 0% 2009 1.71% 1.32% −3.72% 5.68% 1.44% −11.07% −0.4% 2.39 62 63 62 40
3 0% 0% 0% 0% 2009 +100% 2.72% 2.36% −9.86% 12.56% 2.06% −26.57% −3.1% 2.41 34 54 63 79
2 0% 0% 0% 0% 2009 +50% 2.19% 1.91% −6.76% 8.98% 1.68% −18.70% −2.3% 2.39 53 55 59 69
1 0% 0% 0% 0% 2009 1.61% 1.33% −3.69% 5.37% 1.25% −10.75% −1.2% 2.39 64 64 64 52
55 −100% 0% 25% 50% 2006 0.68% −0.07% −0.70% 1.96% 0.85% −2.55% 2.5% 2.41 67 65 65 53
75 −100% −25% 25% 50% 2006 0.88% −0.06% −0.79% 2.52% 1.16% −3.18% 3.8% 2.42 71 68 67 47
15 0% 0% 25% 50% 2006 0.63% −0.06% −0.70% 1.78% 0.73% −2.39% 1.9% 2.41 68 66 66 57
35 0% −25% 25% 50% 2006 0.84% −0.06% −0.78% 2.38% 1.07% −3.04% 3.3% 2.42 72 69 68 49
70 −100% −25% 25% 0% 2006 1.06% 0.09% −0.56% 2.50% 1.29% −3.09% 3.7% 2.43 79 75 69 38
30 0% −25% 25% 0% 2006 1.02% 0.09% −0.54% 2.36% 1.21% −2.95% 3.3% 2.42 78 76 70 42
25 0% −25% 0% 50% 2006 0.25% −0.13% −0.37% 1.04% 0.45% −1.23% 1.9% 2.37 65 67 71 67
50 −100% 0% 25% 0% 2006 0.86% 0.08% −0.48% 1.94% 0.98% −2.47% 2.4% 2.41 75 73 72 51
65 −100% −25% 0% 50% 2006 0.32% −0.13% −0.42% 1.29% 0.58% −1.51% 2.7% 2.38 66 70 74 63
10 0% 0% 25% 0% 2006 0.81% 0.08% −0.47% 1.76% 0.87% −2.30% 1.9% 2.41 74 74 73 54
20 0% −25% 0% 0% 2006 0.44% 0.03% −0.13% 1.03% 0.60% −1.13% 1.9% 2.38 73 77 75 62
60 −100% −25% 0% 0% 2006 0.51% 0.03% −0.18% 1.28% 0.73% −1.41% 2.6% 2.38 76 78 76 60
45 −100% 0% 0% 50% 2006 −0.08% −0.16% −0.25% 0.34% 0.06% −0.40% 1.0% 2.35 69 71 77 74
5 0% 0% 0% 50% 2006 −0.20% −0.16% −0.25% 0.01% −0.16% −0.11% 0.0% 2.34 70 72 78 78
40 −100% 0% 0% 0% 2006 0.12% 0.00% 0.00% 0.33% 0.22% −0.30% 0.9% 2.35 77 79 79 73