Taxes and benefits

Research articles · Aug 31, 2015

Endogenizing take-up of social assistance in a microsimulation model a case study for Germany

Jürgen Wiemers

Institute for Employment Research (IAB), Germany

Volume 8(2) Autumn 2015

Cite as: J. Wiemers; 2015; Endogenizing take-up of social assistance in a microsimulation model a case study for Germany; International Journal of Microsimulation; 8(2); 4–27. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00115

Abstract

Microsimulation studies typically assume that all entitlements to means-tested benefits are actually claimed by eligible households, despite a large body of research that suggests that take-up rates are substantially below 100%. The assumption of full take-up tends to exaggerate the simulated increase in caseloads and fiscal costs of a social policy reform. This paper investigates the impact of non-take-up for two hypothetical scenarios, namely increasing and decreasing the base amount of social assistance in Germany by €100 per month. We find a substantial effect of considering non-take-up on the simulated change in fiscal costs and in particular on the change in caseloads, where the full take-up assumption exaggerates the latter change by a factor of about two.

This article contains 1 figure and 8 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Simulation of welfare entitlements in the IAB-STSM.

Tables

Table 1.
Non-take-up Rate 95%-Confidence Interval
2005 48.0 [43.6–52.5]
2006 42.6 [38.6–46.6]
2007 40.8 [36.7–44.9]
2008 45.3 [40.7–49.9]
2009 38.6 [33.8–43.4]
2010 38.8 [33.4–44.1]
2011 42.8 [37.8–47.8]
Pooled 42.4 [40.7–44.1]

Weighted non -take-up rates in percent. Source: GSOEP years 2005–2011, pooled data, IAB-STSM

Table 2.
Model 1 Probit Model 2 IV Probit Model 3 RE Probit
Simulated monthly benefit (in 100 EUR) .0718*** .0627*** .0745***
(.0016) (.0062) (.0023)
Single .0463*** .0444*** .0278
(.0144) (.0150) (.0244)
Single parent .0529** .0780*** .0506
(.0217) (.0277) (.0358)
Family with children .0112 .0353 .0123
(.0242) (.0299) (.0371)
Number of children aged < = 3 years .0545*** .0699** .0696**
(.0205) (.0230) (.0289)
Number of children age > 14 years −.0410*** −.0345** −.0360*
(.0124) (.0138) (.0184)
HHH retired −.0161 −.0528* .0063
(.0195) (.0306) (.0315)
Disability of HHH .0579 .0588 .1059**
(.0385) (.0402) (.0522)
High qualif. HHH (ref.: med. qual.) −.1322*** −.1375*** −.1824***
(.0158) (.0168) (.0271)
Low qualif. HHH (ref.: med. qual.) .0302** .0420*** .0568***
(.0128) (.0151) (.0216)
Age of HHH .0045*** .0053*** .0042***
(.0004) (.0007) (.0007)
Male HHH .0233** .0310** .0371**
(.0110) (.0124) (.0187)
Home owner household −.1715*** −.1961*** −.2275***
(.0166) (.0224) (.0280)
Rural area (ref.: interm. area) .0369** .0367** .0437
(.0155) (.0162) (.0272)
Metrop. area (ref.: interm. area) −.0016 −.0002 −.0039
(.0111) (.0116) (.0186)
Eastern Germany .1375*** .1447*** .1816***
(.0115) (.0126) (.0200)
EU migrants −.0946*** −.1035*** −.0594
(.0347) (.0374) (.0626)
Non-EU migrants .0111 .0199 .0323
(.0215) (.0231) (.0365)
Migrants with German citizenship .0114 .0156 .0213
(.0137) (.0147) (.0223)
Observations 5960 5960 5960
Wald test of exogeneity: 㱲2(1) 2.88*
(Pseudo)log-likelihood −2749.99 −17327.596 −2369.8414
ρ .717

Source: GSOEP 2005–2011, own calculations. HHH stands for head of household. Wave-dummies included in all models. Standard errors in parentheses.

p < 0.1.

p < 0.05.

p < 0.01.

Table 3.
Change monthly SA by + 100 € −100 €
Take-up 100% TU ETU ETU 100% TU ETU ETU
Share of sunk costs N/A 0 1 N/A 0 1
Caseloads (HH in 1,000)
Social assistance +1,222 +600 +581 −1,143 −528 −333
Housing benefit −506 −336 −338 +856 +561 +558
Enh. child benefit −87 −87 −87 +118 +118 +118
Annual costs in m €
Social assistance (base amount) +6,540 +6,184 +6,157 −5,112 −4,852 −4,467
Social assistance (housing) +4,654 +3,054 +2,990 −4,221 −2,784 −1,945
Housing benefit −449 −356 −358 +1,350 +1,029 +1,029
Enh. child benefit −220 −220 −220 +405 +405 +405
Total effect in m € +10,525 +8,662 +8,569 −7,578 −6,202 −4,978

Notes: A negative sign for the annual total fiscal effect implies a budget surplus.

HH = households, TU = take-up, ETU = endogenous take-up.

Source: Own calculations based on SOEP 2005–2011.

Table 4.
Income components Determined in tax and transfer module?
1 Earned income no
+ Self-employed income no
+ Capital income no
+ Rental income no
+ Other incomes (pensions) no
2 − Social security contributions yes
− Income tax yes
− Alimony payments yes
3 + Child benefit yes
+ Child-raising allowance yes
+ Unemployment benefits yesa
+ Federal student support, stipends, claims to maintenance, widow’s allowance, maternity allowance, reduced hours compensation no
4 + Housing allowance yes
+ Children’s allowance yes
+ Social assistance for employable persons (SGB II) yes
+ Social assistance for unemployable persons (SGB XII) yes
= Net household income yes

Endogenous if labor supply reactions are considered. Otherwise we use reported unemployment benefits.

Source: Bruckmeier and Wiemers(2011).

Table 5.
Utility from SA Claiming costs Effect
Degree of needs Duration of needs Inform. costs Stigma/fear
Calculated monthly benefit (cont.) + +
Singles (ref.: couple without children) + + +
Single parent (ref.: couple without children) + + − +
Family with children (ref.: couple without children) + + ?
Number of children aged < = 3 years + + +
Number of children aged > 14 years − − −
HHH retired + + + ?
Disability of HHH + + − +
High qualif. HHH (ref.: med. qual.) − − ?
Low qualif. HHH (ref.: med. qual.) + + ?
Age, age2 of HHH + + + ?
Male HHH + −
Home owner household − + −
Rural area (ref.: interm. area) + + + ?
Metropolitan area (ref.: interm. area) − − − ?
Eastern Germany + + +
EU migrants + + + + ?
Non-EU migrants + + + + ?
Migrants with German citizenship + + + + ?

Note: Column “effect” indicates the expected effect of the respective variable on the probability of claiming SA. A “+” sign in the utility columns corresponds to a positive expected effect on the probability of take-up, while a “+” sign in the cost columns has the opposite effect (vice versa for “-” signs). A “?” stands for an ambiguous overall effect. “HH” stands for household.

Source: Based on Bruckmeier and Wiemers (2011).

Table 6.
Non-take-up-households Take-up-households
Calculated monthly benefit (in €) 292 662***
Singles 0.56 0 44***
Single parents 0.12 0.21***
Family with children 0.10 0.16***
Number of children aged < = 3 years 0.07 0.15***
Number of children aged > 14 years 0.16 0.24***
HHH retired 0.18 0.08***
Disability of HHH 0.02 0.02
High qualif. HHH (ref.: interm. qual.) 0.22 0.08***
Low qualif. HHH (ref.: interm. qual.) 0.23 0.31***
Age 43.38 44.60***
Male HHH 0.43 0.43
Home owner household 0.18 0.07***
Rural area (ref.: interm. area) 0.12 0.15***
Metropolitan area (ref.: interm. area) 0.40 0.39
Eastern Germany 0.31 0.46***
EU Migrants 0.03 0.02**
Non-EU-Migrants 0.07 0.09*
Migrants with German citizenship 0.19 0.20
Dummy 2006 0.17 0.17
Dummy 2007 0.16 0.16
Dummy 2008 0.16 0.14*
Dummy 2009 0.13 0.15
Dummy 2010 0.11 0.11
Dummy 2011 0.13 0.16
Sample size 2810 3150

Source: GSOEP, authors’ own computations based on IAB-STSM. Stars denote rejection of the E-test on equal means of non-take-up vs. take-up households with the significance levels.

p < 0.1.

p < 0.05.

p < 0.01. HHH = head of household. The sample sizes add up to the number of observations used in the take-up estimations, 5960.

Table 7.
Change monthly SA by +100 € −100 €
Take-up 100% TU ETU ETU 100% TU ETU ETU
Share of sunk costs N/A 0 1 N/A 0 1
Caseloads (HH in 1,000)
Social assistance +1,222 +639 +591 −1,143 −623 −346
Housing benefit −506 −329 −331 +856 +540 +533
Enh. child benefit −87 −87 −87 +118 +118 +118
Annual costs in m €
Social assistance (base amount) +6,540 +6,490 +6,433 −5,112 −5,036 −4,558
Social assistance (housing) +4,654 +3,318 +3,169 −4,221 −3,210 −2,053
Housing benefit −449 −350 −353 +1,350 +1,027 +1,028
Enh. child benefit −220 −220 −220 +405 +405 +405
Total effect in m € +10,525 +9,238 +9,029 −7,578 −6,814 −5,178

Notes: A negative sign for the annual total fiscal effect implies a budget surplus.

HH = households, TU = take-up, ETU = endogenous take-up.

Source: Own calculations based on SOEP 2005–2011.

Table 8.
Change monthly SA by +100 € −100 €
Take-up 100% TU ETU ETU 100% TU ETU ETU
Share of sunk costs N/A 0 1 N/A 0 1
Caseloads (HH in 1,000)
Social assistance +1,222 +637 +620 −1,143 −561 −344
Housing benefit −506 −335 −337 +856 +561 +557
Enh. child benefit −87 −87 −87 +118 +118 +118
Annual costs in m €
Social assistance (base amount) +6,540 +6,326 +6,305 −5,112 −4,915 −4,512
Social assistance (housing) +4,654 +3,246 +3,190 −4,221 −2,925 −2,003
Housing benefit −449 −355 −357 +1,350 +1,028 +1,029
Enh. child benefit −220 −220 −220 +405 +405 +405
Total effect in m € +10,525 +8,997 +8,918 −7,578 −6,407 −5,081

Notes: A negative sign for the annual total fiscal effect implies a budget surplus.

HH = households, TU = take-up, ETU = endogenous take-up.

Source: Own calculations based on SOEP 2005–2011.