Micro-macro linkage

Research articles · Dec 31, 2017

Solving a Partial Equilibrium Model in a CGE Framework: The Case of a Behavioural Microsimulation Model

Xiao-guang Zhang

Productivity Commission, Australia

Volume 10(3) Winter 2017

Cite as: X. Zhang; 2017; Solving a Partial Equilibrium Model in a CGE Framework: The Case of a Behavioural Microsimulation Model; International Journal of Microsimulation; 10(3); 27–58. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00165

Abstract

This paper presents a simple approach to wrapping a computable general equilibrium (CGE) model around a behavioural microsimulation (BMS) model. The approach is akin to decomposing an integrated CGE model into a partial equilibrium (PE) or a BMS model and a ‘residual’ CGE model. This is likely to improve the BMS analysis when changes in labour supply are projected to be large. Specifically, this paper outlines how a household module with many households can be separated from the CGE model and how the resulting PE sub-model and CGE model can be solved iteratively, so that the equilibrium is identical to that obtained with an equivalent fully integrated model. The paper focuses on two challenges that arise when linking and solving the two models: how to find a convergent solution and how to ensure that it is a true general equilibrium solution. This involves ensuring that databases and theory in both models are consistent and fit exactly with each other. Some cases may require the use of a temporary slack variable to facilitate convergence. The approach has the potential to extend the range and quality of the analysis of policy-relevant issues.

This article contains 11 figures and 5 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Variables linking the BMS and the CGE models.
Figure 2a. Convergence in the goods market: import tariff changes.
Figure 2b. Cobweb converging toward equilibrium in goods market: import tariff changes.
Figure 3a. Diverging responses in the goods market without a slack variable: labour supply increase in the BMS model.
Figure 3b. Cobweb converging toward equilibrium in the goods market with saving rate as a slack variable.
Figure 4. Labour supply curves with various elasticities.
Figure 5a. Converging process in labour market: import tariff changes from CGE model to BMS model with flexible labour supply.
Figure 5b. Cobweb converging toward equilibrium in labour market: import tariff changes with flexible labour supply.
Figure 6. Effects of income tax on labour supply of an individual person.
Figure 7a. Converging process in labour market: marginal tax changes from BMS model to CGE model with flexible labour supply.
Figure 7b. Cobweb converging toward equilibrium in labour market: marginal tax changes with flexible labour supply.

Tables

Table 1. Income tax schedule and simulated changes.
Income range ($) Initial tax rates (%) Simulated changes (%) New tax rates (%)
0 - 18,200 0 0 0
18,201 - 37,000 19 5 19.95
37,001 - 80,000 32.5 5 34.13
80,001 -180,000 37 10 40.70
180,001 and above 45 10 49.50

Source: Australian Taxation Office (https://www.ato.gov.au/rates/individual-income-tax-rates/accessed 1 April 2016) and author calculations.

Table B.1. Aggregated input-output table in basic prices (AUD million).
1 ind 2 hou 3 gov 4 inv 5 stk 6 exp 7 mgn Total
1 dom 1,159,672 566,012 265,156 327,917 −2,034 270,578 272,793 2,860,094
2 imp 167,734 79,915 2,878 63,035 3,387 316,949
3 mgn 94,733 127,542 2,672 20,227 −87 27,706 272,793
4 GST 3,624 37,415 0 8,235 0 1,090 50,364
5 tax 17,831 25,502 0 13,609 652 0 57,594
6 sub −6,636 −5,463 0 −1,154 −14 −616 −13,883
7 fac 1,371,108 1,371,108
8 ptx 52,028 52,028
Total 2,860,094 830,923 270,706 431,869 1,904 298,758 272,793 4,967,047

Notes: Basic values of imports (316,949) include import tariffs (3,233).

Source: Compiled from Australian National Accounts: Input-Output Tables, 2012–13 (ABS 5209.0.55.001).

Table B.2. Sources of household income in CGE model and HES-SIH.
CGE model Household Expenditure Survey (HES-SIH)
Wages for eight occupations (same as those in HES-SIH) Managers and administrators; Clerical and administrative workers;
Professionals; Sales workers;
Technicians and trade workers; Machinery operators and drivers;
Community and personal service workers; Labourers;
Capital Own unincorporated business; Superannuation/Annuity/Private pension and other regular sources
Investment;
Transfer payments from government Austudy/Abstudy Partner allowance
Age pension Service pension
Carer allowance Sickness allowance
Carer payment Special benefit
Disability pension War widows pension
Disability support pension Widow allowance
Family tax benefits Wife pension
Newstart allowance Youth allowance
Other pensions and allowances Utilities allowance
Overseas pensions and benefits Senior supplement
Parenting payment Pension supplement
Baby bonus payment;
Direct taxes Income taxes

Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2012.

Table B.3. Comparison between CGE and HES-SIH aggregates (AUD million).
CGE data HES-SIH scaled HES-SIH
(1) (2) original
Expenditure 830,924 830,924 609,468
Income 1,371,109 850,486 623,816
  Labour income 744,282 744,282 545,918
  – Managers & administrators 132,202 132,202 96,968
  – Professionals 229,510 229,510 168,341
  – Technicians & trade workers 101,273 101,273 74,282
  – Community & personal service 45,706 45,706 33,525
  – Clerical & administrative workers work s 91,417 91,417 67,052
  – Sales workers 43,234 43,234 31,712
  – Machinery operators & drivers 50,821 50,821 37,277
  – Labourers 50,118 50,118 36,761
Capital income 626,826 154,400 113,250
  Benefits (23) 106,875 78,391
  Income Tax (-) 155,071 113,742
  Savings 540,185 19,562 14,348

Notes: 1. Capital income in the input-output table is divided between household (154,400) and firm saving (472,426). 2. Scaling factor between columns (2) and (3) = 1.3634.

Table C.1. Sets used in the model and database.
Sets Definitions
COM(1,…,m): Commodities (indexed by c)
IND(1,…,m): Industries (indexed by i)
MCM(1,…,n): Margin commodities (indexed by m)
NCM(= COM - MCM): Non-margin commodities (indexed by c)
FUSR(gov, hou, inv, stk): Final users of commodities (indexed by u)
USR(=IND + FUSR): Users of commodities (indexed by u)
USR_stk(=USR - stk): Users of commodities, exclusive of stk (indexed by u)
SRC(dom, imp): Domestic/import sources of commodities (indexed by s)
FAC(lab,cap): Factors of production (indexed by f)
OCC(1,…,8): Labour occupation (indexed by o)
SAV(inv,stk): Saving destination (indexed by s)
HOU(1,…,9774): Sample households (indexed by h)
PER(1,…,6): Persons in a household (indexed by p)
B23(1,…,23): Transfer payments (indexed by b)
TAX(GST, tax, sub): Three tax items (indexed by g)