Taxes and benefits

Research articles · Aug 31, 2019

Gendered effects of the personal income tax: Evidence from a schedular system with individual filing in Uruguay

Marisa Bucheli, Cecilia Olivieri

Universidad de la República, Montevideo, Uruguay

Volume 12(2) Summer 2019

Cite as: M. Bucheli, C. Olivieri; 2019; Gendered effects of the personal income tax: Evidence from a schedular system with individual filing in Uruguay; International Journal of Microsimulation; 12(2); 69–87. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00202

Abstract

This article analyses the gender differences in the Personal Income Tax in Uruguay. Although the tax code does not explicitly specify gender differences, the average tax rate varies among gendered household types. Using post-tax income data, we simulate the average tax rate of the household and estimate a zero-one inflated beta model -which properly addresses the fact that the average tax rate includes many zero data points- to analyse it. We find that household supported by a one-earner couple bear a higher tax burden than the ones supported by a dual-earner couple or a single parent. We interpret that these findings suggest that the tax serves as somewhat of an incentive towards equal gender time allocation within the family, which is consistent with gender equity. However the strengths of the tax system from the gender perspective are eroded by the possibility to opt for a (rarely used) joint filing.

This article contains 6 figures and 5 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Personal Income Tax burden by income for selected individual types.
Figure 2. Personal Income Tax-to-income ratio for selected couples by participation of one spouse in generating labour income.
Figure 3. Per capita income of households by source.
Figure 4. Average PIT burden and proportion of non-taxpayers by household type
Figure 5. Predicted PIT across percentiles of per capita income distribution for three selected household types.
Figure 6. Predicted PIT across percentiles of per capita income distribution for three selected household types

Tables

Table 1. Socio-demographic characteristics
Uruguay Latin american average
All Women Men W/M All Women Men W/M
Children per woman a/ 2.04 2.14
Life expectancy a/ 77.0 80.5 73.3 1.1 74.8 78.1 71.5 1.1
Population older than 64 b/ c/ 14.0 16.5 11.2 1.5 6.7 7.5 5.9 1.3
Years of education b/ d/ 9.8 10.2 9.5 1.1 8.7 8.7 8.8 1.0
Participation rate b/ c/ e/ 76.1 66.9 85.7 0.8 68.5 54.8 82.6 0.7
Households structureb/ f/
One person households 21.9 11.0
Couple without children 17.2 9.0
Couple with children 33.2 39.9
Lone-parent family 12.0 11.9
Extended households 15.7 28.2

Source: CEPAL (2016) and World Bank (2016).

Notes: a/ 2005–2010; b/ 2010; c/ Percentage of population; d/ Population ages 25–59; e/ Population ages 15–64; f/ Percentage of households.

Table 2. Main characteristics of household categories
Household category Frequency (weighted cases) (%) Households with children (%) Number of members Number of earners Lack of contribution to social security (%) Age of the household head and spouse Number of cases in the sample
All 100 59.8 3.7 1.9 22.5 48.9 124,987
Couple, male breadwinner 18.4 72.4 4.1 1.4 27.3 42.5 22,230
Couple, dual earner 30.7 72.1 3.8 2.3 19.9 41.4 37,082
Couple, female breadwinner 3.2 42.1 3.3 1.9 27.7 52.4 4,033
Couple, non-employed 7.0 9.1 2.6 1.7 4.5 68.5 9,008
Single, male breadwinner 3.2 20.1 1.7 1.2 31.6 47.1 4,125
Single, female breadwinner 7.8 60.6 2.9 1.5 30.4 45.2 11,225
Single, non-employed male 1.3 3.6 1.4 1.1 3.9 70.2 1,886
Single, non-employed female 6.1 22.0 2.2 1.1 9.4 65.9 8,670
Couple, male breadwinner, extended 4.0 83.1 5.8 2.3 34.2 48.5 4,721
Couple, dual earner, extended 4.5 80.5 5.4 3.2 28.1 45.8 5,268
Couple, female breadwinner, extended 0.8 70.1 5.2 2.8 31.2 56.5 943
Couple, non-employed , extended 2.2 65.2 5.0 2.7 14.1 66.5 2,615
Single, male breadwinner, extended 1.7 37.7 3.5 2.2 30.8 44.4 1,976
Single, female breadwinner, extended 4.1 71.8 4.4 2.2 33.7 47.9 5,113
Single, non-employed male, extended 0.8 50.1 3.9 2.0 19.2 65.6 974
Single, non-employed female, extended 4.2 62.8 4.3 2.2 20.1 65.8 5,118

Source: Authors’ calculations based on Encuesta Continua de Hogares 2013, Instituto Nacional de Estadística.

Note: The lack of contribution to social security is calculated at household level as the ratio between non-contributors and workers; the ratio takes value 0 when no one in the household participates in the labour market.

Table 3. Marginal effects estimated by a zero-inflated beta regression
Variables Model 1 Model 2 Model 3
Couple, male breadwinner −0.0067***
(0.00005)
0.0048***
(0.00007)
0.0046***
(0.00007)
Single, female breadwinner −0.0116***
(0.00006)
−0.0141***
(0.00006)
−0.0056***
(0.00007)
Couple, female breadwinner −0.0084***
(0.00008)
−0.0071***
(0.00008)
0.0035***
(0.00009)
Single, male breadwinner −0.0045***
(0.00010)
−0.0184***
(0.00006)
−0.0150***
(0.00010)
Per capita income 0.0205***
(0.00004)
Presence of children (yes =1) 0.0082***
(0.00004)
Household size 0.0041***
(0.00002)
Number of earners (labour, capital earnings or pensions) −0.0044***
(0.00003)
Lack of contribution to social security −0.0001***
(0.00000)
Per capita capital income 0.0574***
(0.00075)
Per capita labour income 0.0286***
(0.00008)
Per capita pension 0.0278***
(0.00009)
Per capita public transfer −0.0036***
(0.00012)
Per capita imputed rent of owner-occupied house −0.0051***
(0.00011)
Observations 124,987 124,987 124,987

Source: Authors’ estimations based on Encuesta Continua de Hogares 2013, Instituto Nacional de Estadística.

Note: For household types, we report the discrete effect related to the “couple, dual earner” type, valuing the rest of the variables at their means. For the rest of the dependent variables, we report the ‘marginal effect’ by household type compared to the “couple, dual earner” type.

***p<0.01, **p<0.05, *p<0.1

Table 4. Marginal effects estimated by a zero-inflated beta regression
Variables Model 1 Model 2 Model 3
Couple, male breadwinner −0.0086***
(0.00004)
0.0022***
(0.00006)
0.0025***
(0.00007)
Single, female breadwinner −0.0107***
(0.00006)
−0.0123***
(0.00006)
−0.0031***
(0.00007)
Couple, female breadwinner −0.0095***
(0.00008)
−0.0081***
(0.00007)
0.0016***
(0.00010)
Single, male breadwinner −0.0036***
(0.00010)
−0.0164***
(0.00006)
−0.0122***
(0.00010)
Per capita income 0.0201***
(0.00004)
Presence of children (yes =1) 0.0084***
(0.00004)
Household size 0.0045***
(0.00002)
Number of earners (labour, capital earnings or pensions)     −0.0044***
(0.00003)
 Lack of contribution to social security −0.0001***
(0.00000)
Per capita capital income 0.0665***
(0.00089)
Per capita labour income 0.0299***
(0.00007)
Per capita pension 0.0302***
(0.00009)
Per capita public transfer −0.0032***
(0.00013)
Per capita imputed rent of owner-occupied house   −0.0054***
(0.00011)
Observations 124,987 124,987 124,987

Source: Authors’ estimations based on Encuesta Continua de Hogares 2013, Instituto Nacional de Estadística.

Note: For household types, we report the discrete effect related to the “couple, dual earner” type, valuing the rest of the variables at their means. For the rest of the dependent variables, we report the ‘marginal effect’ by household type compared to the “couple, dual earner” type.

***p<0.01, **p<0.05, *p<0.1

Table 5. Marginal effects estimated by a zero-inflated beta regression
Variables Model 1 Model 2 Model 3
Single, non-employed female −0.0045***
(0.00013)
−0.0103***
(0.00007)
−0.0128***
(0.00016)
Single, non-employed male −0.0049***
(0.00007)
−0.0105***
(0.00006)
−0.0122***
(0.00011)
Controls No Yes Yes
Observations 124,987 124,987 124,987

Source: Authors’ estimations based on Encuesta Continua de Hogares 2013, Instituto Nacional de Estadística.

Note: The vector of household types includes 16 categories (presented in Table 2); for the estimation we omitted “couple, non-employed”. The rest of the variables are valued at mean. Models 2 and 3 include the control variables shown in tables 3 and 4.

***p<0.01, **p<0.05, *p<0.1