Dynamic microsimulation

Research articles · Dec 31, 2019

A Portable Dynamic Microsimulation Model for Population, Education and Health Applications in Developing Countries

Martin Spielauer, Olivier Dupriez

Consultant for The World Bank Development Data Group, Washington, DC, United States; The World Bank Development Data Group, Washington, DC, United States

Volume 12(3) Winter 2019

Cite as: M. Spielauer, O. Dupriez; 2019; A Portable Dynamic Microsimulation Model for Population, Education and Health Applications in Developing Countries; International Journal of Microsimulation; 12(3); 6–27. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00205

Abstract

Detailed socio-demographic projections are key for policy making and planning. In this paper we introduce the dynamic microsimulation platform DYNAMIS-POP. In its core, DYNAMIS-POP is a population projection model, able to reproduce existing macro (cohort-component based) population projections in their aggregate outcomes, but with the additional possibility to simulate in more detail a variety of geographic, education, ethnicity, child mortality, partnership status, fertility and health characteristics. DYNAMIS-POP is a continuous time interacting population model implemented in Modgen, a freely available programming technology developed at Statistics Canada. The code is also x-compatible with openM++, a platform-independent open-source implementation of Modgen. All components of DYNAMIS-POP are freely available and documented on line at www.dynamis.ihsn.org. Most statistical analysis scripts and scripts for post-processing and visualization of the results are implemented in R. Aiming to support portability, the model code and the R scripts are generic. Adaptation of the model to a specific country only requires adapting a single setup script and simulation module. The model is provided with test data of an imaginary country. Required data are available for most developing countries. To date, the model was tested using data from Mauritania, Nepal and Senegal. Designed as a modular and versatile microsimulation platform, DYNAMIS-POP can be adapted for a variety of applications related to population issues, education and health. In this paper we give an illustration from a study on child vaccination in Nepal.

This article contains 8 figures and 5 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for prenatal care, three scenarios.
Figure 2. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for immunization rates by mother’s education, base scenario w/o prenatal care.
Figure 3. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for immunization rates by mother’s education, four alternative scenarios.
Figure 4. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for immunization rates, six scenarios.
Figure 5. Distribution of mother’s education of one-year old children. DYNAMIS-POP projection and DHS data.
Figure 6. Increase in immunization rates: projected total increases and increases due to composition effects.
Figure A1–1. Age heaping in the 2001 Census of Nepal and its treatment preparing data for DYNAMIS-POP.
Figure A1–2. Underreporting of young children in the 2001 Census of Nepal. The red bars are ‘missing children’ when back-projecting children 0–4 using the number of children born in Nepal age 10–14 in the 2011 Census.

Tables

Table 1. A simplified classification of caste and ethnicities in Nepal according to the The World Bank (2006) study on „Unequal Citizens. Gender, Caste and Ethnic Inclusion in Nepal
% Total population GSEA / NLSS II (10 groups) 2001 census (103 groups)
Hindu caste groups (57.5%) 1.BC (Hill) Brahman, Chhetri, Thakuri, Sanyasi
2.BC (Tarai) Kayashta, Rajput, Baniya, Marwadi, Jaine, Nurang, Bengali
3.Tarai Middle Castes Yadev,Teli, Kalwar, Sudi, Sonar, Lohar, Koiri, Kurmi, Kanu, Haluwai, Hajam/Thakur, Badhe, Rajbhar, Kewat Mallah, Numhar, Kahar, Lodha, Bing/Banda, Bhediyar, Mali, Kamar Dhunia
4.Dalits (Hill) Kami, Damai, Sarki, Gaine, Badi
5.Dalits (Tarai) Chamar, Musahar, Tatma, Bantar, Dhusadadh/Paswan, Khatway, Dom, Chidimar, Dhobi, Halkhor, Unidentified Dalit
Janajatis (37.2%) 6.Newar All Newari Castes
7.Janajatis (Hill) Magar,Tamang, Rai, Gurung, Limbu, Sherpa, Bhote, Walung, Buansi, Hyolmo, Gharti/Bhujel, Kumal, Sunuwar, Baramu, Pahari, Adivasi Janajati, Yakkha, Shantal, Jirel, Darai, Dura, Majhi, Dunuwar, Thami, Lepcha, Chepang, Bote, Raji, Hayu,Raute, Kasunda
8.Janajatis (Tarai) Tharu, Dhanuk, Rajbanshi, Tajpuriya, Gangai, Dhimal, Meche, Kisan, Munda, Santhal/Satar/Dhangad/Jhangad, Koche, Pattarkatta/Kusbadiya
Muslims (4.3%) 9.Muslims Muslim, Churoute
Others (1%) 10.Others
Table 2. Descriptive results of prenatal care and immunization rates. Source: DHS 2001 and DHS 2011, own calculations
Prenatal care Immunization DHS 2001 Immunization DHS 2011
DHS 2001 DHS 2011 No Prenatal Care Prenatal Care All DHS 2001 All DHS 2011
Region Eastern 56.5% 90.6% 61.7% 83.7% 74.1% 87.7%
Central 54.1% 84.7% 46.6% 72.3% 60.5% 83.1%
Western 55.2% 84.1% 44.2% 81.5% 64.8% 91.2%
Mid-West 38.2% 82.1% 60.4% 85.2% 69.9% 84.7%
Far-West 35.5% 91.4% 44.3% 89.7% 60.4% 93.7%
Ethnicity Brahaman/Chhetri 53.5% 89.7% 58.8% 90.2% 75.6% 90.7%
Tarai/Madhesi 54.6% 91.1% 41.5% 66.4% 55.1% 82.0%
Hill Dalits 44.4% 86.8% 53.0% 83.9% 66.7% 87.0%
Tarai/Madhesi Dalits 54.6% 89.0% 37.6% 39.7% 38.8% 83.8%
Newar/Janajati 49.3% 80.5% 56.0% 89.0% 72.3% 93.5%
Muslim 49.9% 89.8% 28.7% 47.1% 37.9% 57.4%
Other 39.1% -- 46.3% 57.1% 50.5% --
Education of mother Never entered school 40.2% 79.6% 47.7% 71.8% 57.4% 78.1%
Primary school dropout 58.0% 88.2% 78.1% 86.8% 83.1% 92.9%
Primary and above 86.2% 93.0% 71.1% 92.2% 89.3% 94.8%
Mother’s age >30 34.9% 70.7% 47.9% 73.5% 56.8% 82.4%
26–30 43.7% 85.1% 48.9% 77.0% 61.2% 86.7%
21–25 52.6% 90.4% 52.9% 84.1% 69.3% 87.8%
18–20 65.0% 89.5% 63.2% 79.7% 73.9% 88.2%
<18 62.8% 90.6% 48.9% 80.7% 68.9% 89.1%
Sex Female 47.8% 84.4% 50.6% 79.4% 64.3% 85.7%
Male 53.0% 88.1% 53.3% 80.5% 67.7% 88.2%
Prenatal care No -- -- -- -- 51.8% 70.3%
Yes -- -- -- -- 79.9% 89.6%
TOTAL 50.3% 86.2% 51.8% 79.9% 65.9% 87.0%
Table 3. Regression results of logistic regression models for prenatal care and immunization based on DHS 2001 and DHS 2011 data. Own calculations. The coefficients are expressed as odds ratios
Prenatal care Immunization DHS 2001 Immunization
DHS 2001 No Prenatal Care Prenatal Care All DHS 2011
Constant 0.626 ** 1.709 5.213 *** 2.419 *** 3.986 ***
Male (Female reference) 1.299 1.052 1.260 * 1.248
Mother entered primary school (No school reference) 1.743 ** 3.926 *** 1.487 2.978 *** 2.779 **
Mother graduated primary education 7.590 *** 2.700 * 2.424 * 4.347 *** 3.444 ***
Central region (Eastern region reference) 0.951 0.526 * 0.591 . 0.581 *** 0.786
Western region 0.754 0.407 ** 0.612 0.479 *** 0.923
Mid-Western region 0.528 ** 0.711 0.782 0.647 * 0.680
Far-Western region 0.459 *** 0.336 ** 0.962 0.374 *** 1.643
Tarai/Madhesi (Brahaman/Chheri reference) 0.447 * 0.360 * 0.457 *** 0.728
Hill Dalits 0.878 0.750 0.851 0.843
Tarai/Madhesi Dalits 0.399 . 0.107 *** 0.240 *** 1.059
Newar and Janajati 0.758 1.091 0.835 1.654
Muslim 0.263 ** 0.147 *** 0.231 *** 0.235 ***
Other 0.570 0.185 *** 0.355 ***
Mother’s birth cohort 1 (25–29 at birth; 30+ reference) 1.199 1.129 1.263 1.185 1.245
Mother’s birth cohort 2 (20–24 at birth) 1.485 * 1.192 2.043 * 1.470 ** 1.170
Mother’s birth cohort 3 ( ≤ 20 at birth) 2.326 *** 1.903 * 1.441 1.808 *** 1.411
Young Mother (age <18; 18+ reference) 0.819 0.408 . 0.919 0.586 ** 0.863
Sample size (n) 1,295 649 646 1,295 943
Table 4. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for prenatal care, three scenarios
Prenatal care scenarios Prenatal care rate
2002 2012 2022 2032
Scenario X0 - Base (used in immunization scenarios A0 and A1) 52.0% 67.2% 76.0% 81.5%
Scenario X1 - Closing regional gaps (used in A2 and A3) 52.0% 71.7% 79.9% 84.8%
Scenario X2 - Closing all prenatal care gaps (use in A4 and A5) 52.0% 90.7% 91.6% 91.7%
Table 5. DYNAMIS-POP simulation projections for immunization rates, six scenarios
Immunization scenarios Immunization rate
2002 2012 2022 2032
Scenario A0 - Base (prenatal care scenario X0 - Base) 68.1% 77.2% 81.3% 83.8%
Scenario A1 - Closing ethnic gaps (prenatal care scenario X0 - Base) 68.2% 83.2% 87.1% 89.3%
Scenario A2 - Closing regional gaps (prenatal care scenario X1 - closing regional gaps) 68.2% 83.8% 86.6% 88.3%
Scenario A3 - Closing ethnic & regional gaps (prenatal care scenario X1 - closing regional gaps) 68.2% 88.8% 91.5% 92.8%
Scenario A4 - Closing ethnic & regional & all prenatal care gaps (prenatal care scenario X2) 68.2% 91.0% 92.4% 93.2%
Scenario A5 - Closing prenatal care gaps only (prenatal care scenario X2) 68.1% 81.7% 83.5% 84.9%