Methodology, Health

Research articles · Aug 31, 2022

The Development of a Microsimulation Model (MitoMOD) to Estimate the Economic Impact of Mitochondrial Disease in Adults

Deborah Schofield, Katherine Lim, Owen Tan, Rupendra Shrestha, Sameen Haque, Karen Crawley, Sarah West, Adam Percival, Jayamala Parmar, Joshua Kraindler, Jinjing Li, Robert Tanton, Carolyn Sue

Centre for Economic Impacts of Genomic Medicine, Macquarie Business School, North Ryde, Australia; Kolling Institute, Royal North Shore Hospital, St Leonards, Australia; National Centre for Social and Economic Modelling (NATSEM), Canberra, Australia

Volume 15(2) Summer 2022

Cite as: D. Schofield, K. Lim, O. Tan, R. Shrestha, S. Haque, K. Crawley, S. West, A. Percival, J. Parmar, J. Kraindler, J. Li, R. Tanton, C. Sue; 2022; The Development of a Microsimulation Model (MitoMOD) to Estimate the Economic Impact of Mitochondrial Disease in Adults; International Journal of Microsimulation; 15(2); 102–111. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00265

Abstract

Mitochondrial diseases (MITO) are serious and debilitating conditions, often multisystemic and requiring life-long monitoring and treatment of symptoms to reduce the risk of a life-threatening episode or acute illness. The disease is caused by mutations either in the mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) or nuclear DNA (nDNA), resulting in impaired production of cellular energy from the affected mitochondrial organelles. MITO closely resembles other conditions due to its wide clinical presentation and genetic heterogeneity. While mitochondrial diseases are relatively common serious conditions with likely large medical and social costs to patients, carers and government, there is no microsimulation model of the impacts of this condition. Further, there is relatively little data on the medical costs of mitochondrial diseases and almost no data on social costs. What data there is on health costs has serious limitations and costs may be significantly underestimated. We aim to address this gap with the development of a microsimulation model called MitoMOD to estimate the costs of mitochondrial diseases using a cohort of clinically diagnosed adult patients with mitochondrial diseases as the base population. In this paper, we describe the construction of MitoMOD which is designed to capture economic impacts on adults clinically diagnosed with mitochondrial diseases, their carer and government. To date, this is the first microsimulation model of its kind.

This article contains 1 figure and 4 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. MitoMOD Microsimulation Model

Tables

Table 1. Study Participant’s Descriptive Statistics
FrequencyPercent
Participant’s Age
 18-3077.3
 31-442324.0
 45-602930.2
 61-742728.1
 75 and over1010.4
Participant’s Gender
 Female6163.5
 Male3536.5
Number of Participants with a Carer
 No Carer6973.4
 Patient Has a Carer2526.6
Number of Participants Partnered
 Not Partnered3840.0
 Partnered5760.0
Number of Participants Whose Spouse is the Carer
 The Participant’s Spouse is not the Carer4171.9
 The Participant’s Spouse is the Carer1628.1
Table 2. Descriptive Statistics of the Carers in EPIC-MITO
FrequencyPercent
Carer’s age
 30-4428.3
 45-60729.2
 61-74833.3
 =>75729.2
Carer’s Gender
 Female1458.3
 Male1041.6
Number of Carers that are Partnered
 Not Partnered28.3
 Partnered2291.7
Number of Carers that live with the Participant
 Lives with the Participant2187.5
 Does not live with the Participant312.5
Table 3. Cost and sources used in MitoMOD
ItemAssigned cost (annual unless otherwise specified)Perspective
Health care
 InpatientAR-DRG (Linked data)Government
 Emergency departmentURG (Linked data)Government
 Alternative medicines and servicesSelf-reportedPrivate
 Healthcare services and treatments, pharmaceutical drugs, outpatient consultationsMBS and PBS Medicare (Linked data)Government and Patient
 Travel costs, meals, accommodation relating to hospital visitsSelf-reportedPatient
 Special diets, remedies, and OTC medicationSelf-reportedPatient
Accommodation
 Residential care$16,973. Income and assets mean tested (for those earning no more than $$27,754 per year)Government and Patient
 Residential care - basic daily fee$18,038
 Respite care (in-home and out-of-home)$13,024
 Public housing25-30% less than market rent
Welfare
 Age pension, Disability pension, Youth allowance, Newstart (Unemployment benefit), Department of Veteran’s Affairs (DVA) pension, Parenting payment, Mobility allowance, AuStudy, Family Tax Benefit, Rent assistance, Carer Payment, Carer allowance, Sickness benefit, OtherSelf-reported or estimated based on rates retrieved and methods for income and asset testing from Services AustraliaGovernment, Patient and Carer
Employment
 Patient’s employmentSelf-reported or synthetically matched to estimate what they could have earnt if they did not have Mito or had to care for the patientGovernment, Patient and Carer
 Patient’s spouse employment
 Carer’s employment
 Carer’s spouse employment
Assistive technologies, modifications to home or car, transport subsidy
 Assistive technologies: Walking aids/crutches, standard wheelchair, electric wheelchair, electric mobility scooter, visual aids (includes glasses), lifting devices, rails, hearing aids, orthotics/special shoes, othersSelf-reportedGovernment and Patient
 Home Modifications: Stairs, external areas, hallways/entrances, kitchen, living room, rails, bedroom/s, bathroom/s, other home modification
 Car modification
 Transport Subsidies: Bus service, taxi transport subsidy scheme, other
Table 4. Estimated population with MITO in the General Population and the estimated number in MitoMOD by Age and Sex
Age GroupFemalesMales
No. in our study*No. in General Population†Estimated No. with MITO in the general populationWeighted Estimate - Develop MITONo. in our Study*No. in the General Population†Estimated No. with MITO in the General PopulationWeighted Estimate - Develop MITO
18-44174,596,12418,38410,873134,607,90418,43214,083
45-59192,440,2469,76112,15272,348,0749,3927,583
60-84252,717,07610,86815,989152,522,98310,09216,250
Total619,753,44639,01439,014359,478,96137,91637,916

Based on current available dataset.

Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics(Australian Bureau of Statistics, 2021)

Note that the youngest age group is relatively under-represented due to the long diagnostic odyssey resulting in delay in diagnosis that patients with MITO face.