Research Article

Research articles · Dec 2, 2024

Firm Turnover and the Rate of Macro Economic Growth: Simulating the Macroeconomic Effects of Schumpeterian Creative Destruction

Gunnar Eliasson, Dan Johansson, Erol Taymaz

The Ratio Institute (and The Royal Institute of Technology), Stockholm, Sweden; Department of Economics, Ankara, Turkey

Volume 17(2) Summer 2024

Cite as: G. Eliasson, D. Johansson, E. Taymaz; 2024; Firm Turnover and the Rate of Macro Economic Growth: Simulating the Macroeconomic Effects of Schumpeterian Creative Destruction; International Journal of Microsimulation; 17(2); 279–296. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00299

Abstract

Investment project selection and firm turnover are integrated in a market self-coordinated macro model (Eliasson, 1976b; Eliasson, 1991a; Eliasson, 1991b; Eliasson, 1995). We simulate a Schumpeterian Creative Destruction process driven by endogenous entrepreneurial entry causing reorganization or exit of firms that acquire and release resources in markets under different institutional conditions. While too fast structural change may make endogenous prices unreliable as conveyors of information, increasing the rate of economic mistakes and slowing econmic growth, an optimal balance between the rate of firm turnover and long run sustainable growth is demonstrated to exist. Optimal growth depends on the balance between entries and exits, the performance and size of new firms compared to incumbents, and on variation in the same characteristics. There is also the general problem associated with selection based, initial state dependent non linear micro based models that the incidence of even minor mistaken investment decisions may cumulate with time into major macro consequences ("deterministic chaos"). We conjecture that the negative tilting (as some "high speed" market entry simulations close up with the 75 year horizon) of the macroeconomic trajectories depends on the incidence of Type II econmic mistakes, or winners getting lost along the way.

This article contains 6 figures and 1 table.

Figures

Figure 1. Salter curves showing labor productivities in Swedish manufacturing 1982 and 1997.
Figure 2. GNP levels at year 15 for different entry rate specifications.
Figure 3. . GNP levels at year 35 for different entry rate specifications.
Figure 4. GNP levels at year 55 for different entry rate specifications.
Figure 5. (A) GNP Levels at Year 75 for Different Entry Rate Specifications.(B) Manufacturing Output Levels at Year 75 for Different Entry Rate Specifications.
Figure 6. (A) Number of net (surviving) entrants in percent of 75 end-year populations of firms for different entry specifications. (B) Number of exits during 75-year simulations in percent of initial number of firms. (C) Number of entrants and exits per year in percent of stock of firms (number) for different entry specifications.

Tables

Table 1. The four mechanisms of schumpeterian creative destruction and economic growth.
1Innovative entry enforces (through competition)
2Reorganization
3Rationalization or
4Exit (bankruptcy and/or shut down)

Source: Eliasson (1996). Note: This is a stylized version on how growth occurs in the micro-to-macro model. We find the term creative destruction appropriate. It first appeared in Schumpeter (1942), but Schumpeter (1911) is a better reference for the dynamics we are discussing.