Environment

Research articles · Apr 30, 2024

Local Natural Capital Influences on the Geospatial Distribution of Farm Incomes

Dilovar Haydarov, Cathal O’Donoghue, Mary Ryan, Chaosheng Zhang

School of Geography, Archaeology and Irish Studies, Galway, Ireland; Teagasc, Athenry, Galway, Ireland

Volume 17(1) Spring 2024

Cite as: D. Haydarov, C. O’Donoghue, M. Ryan, C. Zhang; 2024; Local Natural Capital Influences on the Geospatial Distribution of Farm Incomes; International Journal of Microsimulation; 17(1); 1–22. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00302

Abstract

This paper examines the impact of natural capital characteristics such as soil quality, continentality (regional climatic differences) and environmental (rainfall and temperature) on farm market gross margin. The natural capital variables vary geographically and therefore differentially influence farm outputs and costs depending on location. In order to account for the geospatial heterogeneity of natural capital, we use a system of equations known as an income generation model that incorporates physical capital, human capital, and natural capital to adjust the data within the geospatial microsimulation model. In our model, we utilise agricultural administrative and National Farm Survey data. The incorporation of the geospatial heterogeneity due to local variations in natural capital results in considerable adjustments in simulated agricultural incomes across the case study country: Ireland, reflecting agronomic differences arising from the natural capital condition. The results show that after incorporating natural capital drivers into our model, market gross margin per hectare increased in the South and South-East. In contrast, sub-catchment level gross margin per hectare values decreased in the Midlands and parts of the North. Decomposing the variation in income between districts and within districts, we find that accounting for heterogeneity in natural capital also reveals greater income variability, particularly in relation to between-district variability. The outputs of the study demonstrate the impact of natural capital on farm income and the importance of accounting for localised environmental and agronomic conditions.

This article contains 3 figures and 9 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Monthly mean gross margin per hectare by soil types (€).. Source: Author calculations using Teagasc NFS (2014).
Figure 2. Market Gross Margin per Hectare Sampled and Simulated (based on Jenks or Natural Breaks Classification).
Figure 3. Market gross margin per hectare variation.

Tables

Table 1. Stocking rate and purchased feed requirements in different regions.
Livestock Unit (LU) per HaFeed (€) per LU
Land AreaNorth/BorderSESWNorth/BorderSESW
< 20 Ha1.682.392.22163.997.1120.1
20-30 Ha1.702.282.28253.5280.3345.4
30-50 Ha1.782.132.12347.3223.5265.3
>= 50 Ha1.842.101.90339.8188.6256.9

Source: Teagasc National Farm Survey 2014.

Note: LU per Ha – Stocking rate or livestock units per hectare; Feed (€) per LU - Purchased feed per livestock unit.

Table 2. Comparison of survey and administrative data.
NFSAdministrative Data
system<= 20 Ha20-30 Ha30-50 Ha50+ HaTotal<= 20 Ha20-30 Ha30-50 Ha50+ HaTotal
Dairy1.12.411.120.835.40.41.13.66.111.2
Cattle Rearing0.73.46.64.415.17.63.94.21.917.5
Cattle Other2.53.67.811.425.415.77.68.55.637.5
Sheep1.41.74.05.812.94.82.02.62.411.9
Tillage0.51.01.45.78.62.21.11.72.67.7
Mixed0.00.20.32.12.60.60.30.40.62.0
Other Pasture Farms (Rental, Silage, Grazing)0.00.00.00.00.05.00.70.56.212.3
Total6.212.331.250.3100.036.316.721.525.4100.0
Table 3. Summary statistics of agronomic & environmental variables.
Variable NameMeanSt. DevMinMax
Spring grass growth rate (dry matter kg/ha)9.336.36-19.3730.32
Spring grass cover (ha)6500.25728.793176.468575.78
Mean_Rain (annual average, mm)107.6423.8060.25246.47
Mean_Temp (annual average, °C)9.070.604.6710.76
Soil1 (binary)0.170.3701
Soil2 (binary)0.810.3901
Soil3 (binary)0.010.1201
Table 4. Sampled and simulated dependent variable (summary statistics).
VariableObsMeanStd. DevMinMax
Sampled Gross Margin (€)farmgm_ha111,369483.27705.46-1185.0213377.3
Simulated Gross Margin (€)si_farmgm_ha111,369483.24802.28-6325.1974604.22
Table 5. Average Changes at County level for Sampled and Simulated Market Gross Margin per Ha
Market Gross Margin per Ha (€)Market Gross Margin per Ha relative to national average (€)Ratio
SampledSimulatedSampledSimulated
CountyRegionABCDD/CB/A
CarlowSE1094.61147.81.131.241.101.05
CavanNW860.2735.70.890.790.900.86
ClareMW760.4722.50.780.781.000.95
CorkSW1617.81584.11.671.711.030.98
DonegalNW688.8515.70.710.560.790.75
DublinE902.2935.20.931.011.091.04
GalwayW655.0626.00.670.681.000.96
KerrySW1129.3996.21.161.080.930.88
KildareE988.31033.61.021.121.101.05
KilkennySE1475.21528.01.521.651.091.04
LaoisM1093.71093.81.131.181.051.00
LeitrimNW531.2387.50.550.420.770.73
LimerickMW1384.31386.61.421.501.051.00
LongfordM631.3589.10.650.640.980.93
LouthNE933.6905.90.960.981.020.97
MayoW564.8482.70.580.520.900.85
MeathE1030.01072.11.061.161.091.04
MonaghanNE837.8725.70.860.780.910.87
OffalyM925.9922.70.951.001.051.00
RoscommonW576.9534.80.590.580.970.93
SligoNW600.9524.10.620.570.910.87
TipperaryMW/SE1380.21410.81.421.521.071.02
WaterfordSE1564.91650.91.611.781.111.05
WestmeathM857.5883.80.880.951.081.03
WexfordSE1490.01575.51.531.701.111.06
WicklowE1127.71089.11.161.181.010.97
Total971.6926.41.001.001.000.95

NB = This analysis focuses on primarily on pastoral farms; E = East; M = Midlands; NE = North East; N = North West; SE = South East; SW = South West; W = West;

Table 6. Within and between group variation in market gross margin per hectare.
Baseigm3
GE(2)GiniGE(2)Gini
Total1.0560.6771.2070.712
Within0.9601.088
Between0.0960.119

NB = This analysis focuses on primarily on pastoral farms;

The Geospatial unit is sub-catchment.

Table 7. Statistical significance of changes in Farm Market Gross Margin per hectare and its components.
SampledSimulated
LBUBMeanMeanRatio Simulated: SampledStatistically Different
All Farms
Market Gross Margin per Ha9649809729260.951
Market Gross Output Per Ha13981418140813360.951
Farm Direct Costs per Hectare4344394374090.941
Dairy Farms      
Dairy Livestock Units per Ha1.831.851.841.871.011
Dairy Gross Output per Livestock Units18581869186418220.981
Cattle Farms      
Cattle Livestock Units per Ha1.331.341.331.260.951
Cattle Gross Output per Livestock Units5655685675410.961
Sheep Farms      
Sheep Gross Output per Livestock Units1.591.601.591.380.871
Farm Direct Costs per Hectare4644694664410.951

NB = LB stands for Lower Bound and UB for Upper Bound;

The Lower Bound represents the minimum level of gross output, gross margin, direct costs, etc. that farms have within the simulation, while the Upper Bound represents the maximum level of gross output, gross margin, direct costs, etc. The "Statistically Different" column with a value of 1 represents that the change in mean is significantly different from zero and has a probability of less than 5% of being random in terms of the mean being different from zero.

Table A1. Regression model of market gross margin per hectare as a function of natural capital variables.
Explanatory VariablesCoef.Std. Err.tMean (Survey Data)Mean (SMILE-GIS)
Acid Brown Earth 70%0.30.30.920.0060.000
Acid Brown Earth 70% (Coarse texture)0.40.31.310.0080.000
Acid Brown Earth 75%0.50.22.050.0400.000
Acid Brown Earth 90%1.20.42.730.0110.000
Basin Peat 100%-0.61.5-0.41-0.0100.000
Blanket Peat (Low level) 100%-0.10.4-0.28-0.0010.000
Brown Podzolic 60%0.10.20.610.0160.000
Brown Podzolic 80%0.20.40.490.0070.000
Degraded Grey Brown Podzolic 50%-0.50.3-1.68-0.0140.000
Gley 50%-0.30.3-1.08-0.0110.000
Gley 60%0.21.50.130.0020.000
Gley 75%0.40.21.510.0240.000
Gley 80%0.11.50.080.0020.000
Gley 90%-0.41.4-0.29-0.0190.000
Grey Brown Podzolic 60%-0.10.3-0.33-0.0040.000
Grey Brown Podzolic 70%0.20.30.880.0110.000
Grey Brown Podzolic 75%0.30.31.010.0090.000
Grey Brown Podzolic 80%0.50.31.640.0170.000
Island not surveyed-0.90.4-2.26-0.0110.000
Lithosols and Outcropping Rock 70%0.80.23.570.0840.000
Minimal Grey Brown Podzolic 70%0.40.21.480.0260.000
Peaty Gley 70%-1.10.3-4.18-0.0470.000
Peaty Podzol 75%-1.20.5-2.65-0.0100.000
Podzol 70%0.40.70.590.0010.000
Distance to Sea0.00.0-1.53-0.1120.000
Average Temperature-0.10.0-5.09-1.1440.000
Average Rainfall0.00.0-5.7-1.6730.000
Flat to Undulating Lowland (Mainly dry-0.30.2-1.11-0.0910.000
Flat to Undulating Lowland (Mainly wet0.41.40.260.0330.000
Hill0.00.30.090.0020.000

Source: Teagasc National Farm Survey and Simulation Model of the Irish Local Economy.

Table A2. Gross output estimation.
Dep varDairyDairyCattleCattleSheepSheepCereal
Livestock Units/HaOutput per livestock unitLivestock Units/HaOutput per livestock unitLivestock Units/HaOutput per livestock unitOutput per livestock unit
Obs4966495713,93313,845486047722987
R20.42250.38410.51570.26660.59760.18910.2276
Price0.000045*** 0.0001*** 0.0001***  
Fertiliser per ha 0.0815*** 0.0783***0.2295***0.033*0.2196***
Purchased concentrate per Ha 0.1525*** 0.0988***0.0147*0.0981*** 
Share of enterprise area usage  -0.2927***-0.3804***  -0.125***
Stocking rate for the enterprise -0.0812*** -0.1345***-0.2149***-0.0513** 
Labour (Log)0.0542***-0.01060.07940.0419***0.1001***0.0829***0.0172
Age (Log)-0.024***-0.0122-0.0129**-0.00150.00070.0267-0.0347
Has an off-farm job -0.0109 0.0139-0.0143-0.01-0.0171
Farm size (Log)-0.132***0.0565***-0.1142***  0.028 
Has forestry -0.0259 -0.0221 -0.04990.1501***
Extension service-0.00550.00770.00670.0289***-0.00150.00350.0052
Agri-environmental Sch0.0121*0.0129**0.00770.0001-0.018*0.0325*0.021
Constant-22.671***-5.7243***-6.2127***19.4944***-0.8441***14.55257.0117***
Sigma u0.17980.1936***0.2523***0.3014***0.3075***0.4936***0.4378***
Sigma e0.13290.1343***0.179***0.3293***0.2426***0.4209***0.3392***
Rho0.64660.67530.66510.45580.61640.57910.6249

Source: O’Donoghue (2017).