Housing, Environment

Research articles · Aug 31, 2022

A Microsimulation Model for the Land Rental Market in Irish Farming

Jason Loughrey, Thia Hennessy

Teagasc Rural Economy and Development Programme, Galway, Ireland; Cork University Business School, Cork, Ireland

Volume 15(2) Summer 2022

Cite as: J. Loughrey, T. Hennessy; 2022; A Microsimulation Model for the Land Rental Market in Irish Farming; International Journal of Microsimulation; 15(2); 77–101. doi: 10.34196/ijm.00264

Abstract

In this paper, we utilize Teagasc National Farm survey data to analyse the agricultural land rental market in Ireland with a newly developed agent-based microsimulation (ABM) model and a classical walrasian equilibrium model of the land rental market. We conclude that the microsimulation model has a number of strengths in addressing the interactions between landowners and tenants and dealing with the impact of economic changes on the farm size concentration. The equilibrium model retains some value in dealing with the question of price determination and in illustrating the potential surpluses to be gained from a more active land rental market. The paper contains a comparison of simulation results from the ABM model with recent farm-level data and Census of Agriculture data. These comparisons indicate the relevance of some findings from the simulation model including the rise in average dairy farm size and the decline in area allocated to non-dairy cattle farming. However, the sheep farming system appears to have defied the predictions from the simulation model and this may be attributed to the recent improvement in economic performance for this sector. The ABM model can be further refined to account for decisions in relation to the choice of farming system, the question of retirement and farm exit.

This article contains 6 figures and 11 tables.

Figures

Figure 1. Description of the Agent-Based Model of the Agricultural Land Market
Figure 2. Market for Good Agricultural Land in South-West and Mid-West Region
Figure 3. Market for Good Agricultural Land in East Region
Figure 4. Market for Good Agricultural Land in BMW Region
Figure A1. Total Number of Agricultural Land Rental Transactions in Ireland Qualifying for Relief from Rental Income. Source: Revenue (2021)
Figure A2. Share of Family Labour in Total Labour by Farm Size (Ha.). Source: Authors calculations using Teagasc National Farm Survey 2017**Tillage farms excluded

Tables

Table 1. Summary Statistics for Six Regional Markets
RegionSoil QualityNo. FarmsWeighted No. FarmsUAA (Ha.)Rental Share
South-West, Mid-WestGood1159,470428,76016.5%
EastGood19417,400822,73321.9%
BMWGood16719,366773,37415.6%
BMWMedium20025,532881,53220.3%
South-West, Mid-WestMedium766,920284,19016.8%
EastMedium756,427318,10418.4%

Source: Authors calculations using Teagasc National Farm Survey from 2017.

Table 2. Rental Price Statistics for Six Regional Markets
RegionSoil QualityMedian Rented Price (€)25th Percentile of Rented Price75th Percentile of Rented Price
South-West, Mid-WestGood362250441
EastGood354250431
BMWGood252209355
BMWMedium223150291
South-West, Mid-WestMedium314240410
EastMedium250222357

Source: Authors calculations using Teagasc National Farm Survey from 2017.

Table 3. Simulated Average Farm Size by System
SystemAverage Farm Size (Ha.)Average Farm Size [Post-Simulation]Change in Farm Size (Ha.)
Dairying58.473.615.2
Cattle33.527.6-5.9
Sheep46.938.2-8.7
Other73.783.59.8
Tillage59.164.85.6

Source: Teagasc NFS 2017 and Author’s simulations using Teagasc NFS 2015-2017.

Table 4. Simulated Share of Agricultural Land by System
SystemInitial ShareShare Post-SimulationPercentage Change
Specialist Dairying24.0%31.5%7.4%
Cattle46.0%39.3%-6.7%
Sheep17.1%14.4%-2.6%
Other2.5%3.0%0.4%
Tillage10.3%11.8%1.4%
Table 5. Change in Average Farm Size by System 2017 to 2020
SystemAverage Farm Size 2017 (Ha.)Average Farm Size 2020 [Ha.]Change in Farm Size (Ha.)Average Farm Size 2020 [Ha.]Change in Farm Size (Ha.)
2017 Weights2020
Weights
Dairying58.461.73.365.97.5
Cattle33.533.60.131.5-2.0
Sheep46.947.30.449.52.6
Tillage59.161.72.673.214.1

Source: Teagasc NFS 2017 and 2020.

Table 6. Total Agricultural Area by Farming System 2010-2020
System2010
(Ha.)
2020
(Ha.)
Change
(Ha.)
Percentage ChangePercentage Change in Share of Land
Dairying865,666997,267131,60115.2%3.2%
Cattle2,153,3431,994,877-158,466-7.4%-2.9%
Sheep417,494503,87286,37820.7%2.0%
Tillage268,520290,46121,9418.2%0.6%
Mixed Grazing Livestock527,622381,158-146,464-27.8%-3.1%
Mixed Crops And Livestock137,541114,159-23,382-17.0%-0.5%
Mixed Field Crops162,832186,55923,72814.6%0.6%
Other33,03837,0774,03912.2%0.1%

Source: Censuses of Agriculture 2010 and 2020.

Table 7. Farm Size Inequality by Group under Profit Maximisation
GroupRegionSoil TypeInitial Gini Coefficient 2017 DataGini Coefficient [Simulation]Gini Coefficient 2020 Data
1South-West, Mid-WestGood35.845.036.8
2EastGood39.847.442.8
3BMWGood36.250.842.7
4South-West, Mid-WestMedium31.748.937.4
5EastMedium32.449.938.1
6BMWMedium32.441.838.0
Table 8. Mid-Point Hectare Statistic by Group under Profit Maximisation
GroupRegionSoil TypeInitial Midpoint HectareMidpoint Hectare [Post-Simulation]Midpoint Hectare 2020
1South-West, Mid-WestGood587367
2EastGood647766
3BMWGood456759
4South-West, Mid-WestMedium477250
5EastMedium629164
6BMWMedium404641
Table 9. Progressivity or Regressivity of Distribution in Post-Simulation
GroupRegionSoil TypeProgressivity+
Regressivity-
1South-West, Mid-WestGood+0.047
2EastGood-0.006
3BMWGood+0.013
4South-West, Mid-WestMedium-0.059
5EastMedium-0.059
6BMWMedium+0.029
Table A1. Description of Soil Categories
Soil CategoryDescription
Good Soils (Classes 1 and 2)Soils of wide use range have no limitations which cannot be overcome by normal management practices or
Moderately wide use-range refers to soils with minor limitations such as coarse texture, moderately high altitude, less favourable climatic conditions, somewhat shallow depth, hummocky topography and somewhat weak structure.
Medium Soils (Classes 3 and 4)The somewhat limited use range category is used for soils with similar limitations to those of Class 2 but these are present to a greater degree. For example, soils with altitude limitations in this category usually occur between 150 m and 365 m, whereas those of the moderately wide use range with altitude limitations are at elevations mostly between 90 and 150 m
Soils in this category- are generally unsuited to tillage but suited to a permanent grassland system. The predominant limitation is poor drainage
Poor SoilsThis class contains those soils whose agricultural potential is greatly restricted. They are widespread in the western and north-western regions, particularly in the mountain zones where high altitude and steep slopes are major limitations.

Source: Teagasc National Farm Survey

Table A2. Assumptions of the ABM and Equilibrium Models
ABM modelEquilibrium Model
TimeTransactions take place under an iterative sequential processTransactions occurring instantly at an equilibrium price
Price DeterminationBilateral negotiation between landowner and potential tenant with reference to prevailing rental pricesRental prices are determined solely by aggregate supply and aggregate demand
Capitalisation of Direct Payments50 per cent of the value of direct payments are added to each bid and each reservation price50 per cent of the value of direct payments are added to each bid and each reservation price
Reservation pricesThe landowner makes decisions with reference to a reservation price, below which the landowner will not release land to the marketThe landowner makes decisions with reference to a reservation price, below which the landowner will not release land to the market
Farming SystemAssumed that farms remain in their current farming system.Assumed that farms remain in their current farming system.
Farm Size LimitsLimits on farm size growth can be enforced by a central authority at the regional or national level.No assumptions to restrict farm size growth
Rental ShareThe land rental market comes to a close when the land rental share in the region reaches 30 per cent. This prevents farm exits from occuring.No assumptions around rental share and farm exits may occur
Bid ValuesThe recent history of farm profitability is used to form predictions about future profitability and these predictions underline the bids and reservation prices for particular land parcels.The recent history of farm profitability is used to form predictions about future profitability and these predictions underline the bids and reservation prices for particular land parcels.
Costs of ScaleDecreasing returns to scale - Farmers who expand beyond a certain threshold are assumed to encounter additional costs associated with the purchase of new machinery, livestock and buildings.Constant returns to scale
Initial StateWe do not assume that the initial state of the land market is perfectly competitive.
Land TenureAssume rented and owned land are farmed to the same profitabilityAssume rented and owned land are farmed to the same profitability
IntermediaryAssumed that a market agent mediates between the land owner and tenant in negotiating each individual transactionWalrasian auctioneer